21 Aug 2014
77° Clear
Patch Instagram photo by patch
Patch Instagram photo by akissofnaturespa
Patch Instagram photo by tayjac_sulek666

What Should Fill the Pure Oil Building?

Visions for Vacancies: What should fill a filling station? The Pure Oil building dates back to the 1930s, but should it be preserved or redeveloped?

What Should Fill the Pure Oil Building? What Should Fill the Pure Oil Building? What Should Fill the Pure Oil Building? What Should Fill the Pure Oil Building? What Should Fill the Pure Oil Building?
  • Editor's note: I'm writing this before I go on vacation. The Geneva City Council Committee of the Whole was expected to discuss the possible demotion of the Pure Oil Building, 502 W. State St., at a meeting scheduled for Monday, March 26. The discussion or decisions made at that meeting could render this article moot. But unless there is a clear mandate to move forward with the proposed bank drive-through, the question of how the property should be developed will be more pertinent than ever.

 

There is no pure solution to the problem of how to develop the former Pure Oil Building property at 524 W. State St.

On one hand, you have a building with a limited square footage—not enough to attract most retail businesses. It's a building without insulation and a facade that is falling apart in places. It was built in the 1930s, heated with steam, and its owner, Joe Stanton, says it would cost $360,000 to restore.

And that's if there were a buyer out there who would want to spend that kind of money.

On the other hand, you have one of the few remaining "English cottage" style gas stations built by the Pure Oil Company in the 1920s and '30s. Many of the remaining stations are on national, state and local registers of historic places—and this one was deemed "significant" to the Geneva Historic District and "contributing" to our National Historic District.

This Pure Oil station was built by August Wilson, a well-known Geneva general contractor, who was "complimented on the excellent work done thruout the job," according to a Dec. 3, 1937, edition of The Geneva Republican. (The word "thruout" was spelled that way purposefully, using the old Chicago style popularized by the Chicago Tribune.)

What's proposed right now is to tear down the former service station and attach a bank drive-through to the building next door, the first floor of which would become the home of the St. Charles Bank & Trust. The artist's renderings show a modern drive-through with a historic architectural flavor, landscaping and a good deal of additional parking that would help the downtown area.

Neither the status quo nor the proposed bank drive-through are perfect. Any and all creative solutions are welcomed.

Should the building be preserved, and if so, what would be a practical use for it? Is its present use as the home of The Pure Gardener something that should continue? Is the bank drive-through the best possible solution to a thorny problem? Or is there are better answer, some idea that could save the history and help the property to become more economically viable?

Patch is asking you: What would you like to see in the Pure Oil property? Share your ideas in the comments section below.

Share This Article