Statements released this week in Stoughton District Court reveal that Barry Starr, a former rabbi at Temple Israel of Sharon, allegedly had a sexual relationship with a 16-year-old boy, and paid off a Milton man for his silence about the situation, reported the Boston Globe. The Milton man said he was the teen's older brother.
Starr allegedly transferred money to Nicholas Zemeitus, 29, of Milton, who then accused the rabbi of suggesting he alter the checks. The statements also allege that Starr used donations to the congregation as part of the pay-off money, said the Globe.
Zemeitus originally met with Starr through an ad on Craigslist's "casual encounters," when he posed as a middle aged woman, said the Globe.