Politics & Government

State's Planned Parenthood De-Funding Led To Spike In Medicaid-Paid Childbirths

UT-Austin study also shows women turned to less effective contraceptives after limited access to clinics in the wake of funding cutoffs.

AUSTIN, TX -- The state’s de-funding of Planned Parenthood in Texas resulted in a marked decrease in women using the most effective types of contraception along with a rise in Medicare-paid childbirth, University of Texas at Austin researchers found in a study.

Published in the New England Journal of Medicine on Feb. 3, the peer-reviewed study found that use of long-acting contraception fell by a third while births paid for by Medicaid rose by 27 percent.

“This change is worrisome, since increased access to long-acting, reversible contraception methods is a priority of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists,” UT-Austin researchers wrote. “And one study has indicated substantial unmet demand for long-acting, reversible contraception methods in Texas.”

Find out what's happening in Austinfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Planned Parenthood has increasingly been in the political cross-hairs of Texas lawmakers, particularly among conservative legislators running on records opposing abortion -- one of the offerings offered by Planned Parenthood along with general medical care.

As a result of the ideologically based opposition, “Texas is one of several states that have barred Planned Parenthood affiliates from providing health care services with the use of public funds,” researchers explained in the study.

Find out what's happening in Austinfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Planned Parenthood provides mostly low-income women women health care services through clinics often set up in densely populated communities.

In preparing their study, researchers examined administrative records assessing the rates of contraception provision, along with childbirths covered by Medicaid from 2011 to 2014.

The years of study compared results before and after the state excluded Planned Parenthood affiliates from a publicly funded women’s health program administered by the state.

Since the funding exclusion, 35 percent fewer claims were made for long-acting, reversible contraceptives such as implants and intrauterine devices.

Another 31 percent fewer claims were made for injectable contraceptives such as Depo-Provera.

No significant changes were found in the provision of short-term acting hormonal contraceptives -- contraceptive pills, patches, rings, and the like -- researchers found.

“Providers who are mission-driven and have the requisite experience and knowledge are critical in providing the most effective methods of contraception -- IUDs, implants and injectables,” Joseph Potter, director of the Texas Policy Evaluation Project and professor in the university’s Population Research Center, said.

“From a demographic perspective, this is important because these methods dramatically decrease unintended pregnancy,” Potter said. “We also have accumulating evicence of an unet demand for these methods in Texas.”

Limited clinic access resulting from de-funding also led to more women relying on Medicaid to have their babies delivered, the study found. The 27 percent increase in Medicaid-paid childbirth was among women who received injectable contraceptives prior to the Planned Parenthood funding bans.

“This study isolates the effect of the exclusion not only on the delivery of services, but also on subsequent deliveries paid by Medicaid, said lead author Amanda Stevenson, a Ph.D candidate in sociology.

“We examined differences between counties that had Planned Parenthood affiliates versus those that did not to determine how the public was affected once affiliates could no longer use public funds to provide contraceptive services,” Stevenson added.

The Women’s Health Program was once 90 percent federally funded as a Medicaid waiver program. But in 2013, it was replaced by the state-funded Texas Women’s Health Program.

Both programs provided services to female residents between the ages of 18 to 44, with incomes at or below 185 percent of the federal poverty level.

Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America, suggested the findings bore out the worst fears of those advocating for women’s access to health care and contraceptives.

“This new research shows the devastating consequences for women when politicians block access to care at Planned Parenthood. Politicians have claimed time and again that our patients can simply go to other health care providers — and tragically that’s not the case,” she said.

“Instead, women were left out in the cold,” she added.

Long opposed by conservative lawmakers, Planned Parenthood became a further flash-point of controversy last April. Two anti-abortion activists secretly filmed video purporting to show clinic operators talking about selling fetal tissue and other parts for profit.

After an investigation, Planned Parenthood was cleared of all wrongdoing and misconduct, and the video was later found to have been heavily edited and manipulated in its attempt at exposé. Instead, a grand jury handed down indictments against the anti-abortion activists related to their tactics.

The two anti-abortion activists turned themselves in this week.

At the federal level, the House of Representatives this week failed to override a presidential veto of a bill aimed at de-funding Planned Parenthood. The final vote on the effort was 241-186.

>>> Image via Wikimedia Commons