Jul 28, 2014

McKenna vs Inslee: Who Won the First Gubernatorial Debate?

The Association of Washington Business hosted the first gubernatorial debate between former Congressman Jay Inslee (D) and State Attorney General Rob McKenna (R). You can watch the replay on TVW.

McKenna vs Inslee: Who Won the First Gubernatorial Debate?

You can watch TVW's replay of the first gubernatorial debate between former Congressman Jay Inslee (D) and State Attorney General Rob McKenna (R).

Go here to watch the debate on TVW's website, or you can watch the embedded video above. 

The two are the expected front runners in the race to replace outgoing Gov. Chris Gregoire, who announced last year that she will step down after two terms.

McKenna, of Bellevue, and Inslee, of Bainbridge Island, will square off on the ballot box for the first time in the August 7 primary. Washington is a "top two" primary state, which means that the top two vote-getters regardless of party will proceed to the general election.

Both sides made the cases that each one did well, with press releases after the debate:

From McKenna's camp:

McKenna Shines in First Gubernatorial Debate

Washington voters had their first opportunity to evaluate the leading candidates for governor side-by-side this afternoon in a debate hosted by the Association of Washington Business and Greater Spokane, Inc. at the Bing Crosby Theater in Spokane. Attorney General Rob McKenna gave an inspired, energetic performance that reinforced his campaign’s themes - calls for proven education reforms, addressing regulatory and workforce issues to jump-start job growth, and a leadership-driven culture change in Olympia to make state government leaner, more efficient, and less expensive.

“I had a lot of fun today and I hope we can arrange to do it again soon,” said McKenna. “More importantly, I think the voters really benefit from a robust exchange of ideas. I promised a year ago that my campaign would be focused on substantive policy positions instead of merely generating soundbites. I think we’ve lived up to that promise and will continue to do so through Election Day.

“I laid out my case to the voters today and hope I proved that its time to end the same old approach to governing in Olympia,” continued McKenna. We can go in a New Direction and I can provide the fresh leadership necessary to get us there.”

McKenna’s opponent, former Congressman Jay Inslee, seemed to ignore pre-debate media criticism and remained elusive in his responses to moderator Austin Jenkins’ questions. Inslee did manage to show imagination in sporadic attacks on McKenna.

“I am glad to see that after all of the back-and-forth and excuses, Congressman Inslee showed for the debate,” said Charles McCray III, McKenna’s communications director. “That being said, I’m disappointed that the Congressman dodged so many questions posed to him. Calls for Mr. Inslee to take a position on several difficult policy topics have been constant. Unfortunately, I don’t think anyone who watched today’s debate was left with a clear view of what the Congressman would actually do if he was elected governor.

“The Congressman did manage to deliver his scripted stump speech over the course of the afternoon,” continued McCray. “From it, we know that the Inslee jobs plan is a re-heated version of the failed federal stimulus that would gamble taxpayer dollars on picking economic winners and losers instead of simply making it more affordable for all small businesses to hire. While Rob wants to focus on finding solutions to the challenges that face Washington, Mr. Inslee is obsessed with the ‘virus of Wisconsin’ and a host of other national talking points provided by his special interest allies. It was a lackluster performance. Perhaps Mr. Inslee will want another shot after reviewing the tape and decide to agree to at least one more of the 13 remaining debates proposed by the McKenna campaign.”


From Inslee's camp:

Inslee successfully reveals contrast with McKenna on key issues of jobs, economic development

SPOKANE – Today, the leading gubernatorial candidates squared off at the Association of Washington Business spring meeting in Spokane for their first debate of the campaign. The debate focused primarily on issues such as economic development, job creation and the state budget.

Jay Inslee, the Democratic candidate, emphasized that jobs will be his number one priority as governor and reaffirmed his commitment to rebuilding Washington’s middle class.

“I have lived on both sides and worked on both sides of the Cascades," said Inslee. "I have a deep understanding of our state and an abiding faith in our ability to move forward. Washingtonians are an innovative people - we create, we invent, we build. We have led technological revolutions in aerospace and ecommerce. Now we are on the cusp of a technological revolution in clean energy and biotech, and I believe it is our destiny to again lead the world.”

While Rob McKenna repeatedly resorted to generic, recycled Republican talking points, Inslee offered specific strategies tailored to Washington’s strengths in manufacturing, clean technology, life sciences and other key industries.

Inslee is a recognized leader in clean tech, and has also successfully worked to open up trade for Washington apples into Japan, protect aerospace jobs against unfair foreign competition, and strengthen Washington's IT and biotech industries. Inslee’s jobs plan is supported by a wide range of industry leaders who say the policies will help bolster growth and create jobs.

"As a small business owner in eastern Washington it is clear to me after listening to today's debate that Jay understands how to grow our economy and position us all for a strong future," said Phil Cline, owner of Naches Valley Heights Vineyard in Yakima.

McKenna, who is expected to be endorsed by the right-leaning Association of Washington Business and has benefitted from fundraisers hosted by corporations such as Tesoro and payday lender Ace Cash, repeated often-used refrains of deregulation and reform, but provided few specifics.

Other issues discussed included education, transportation and who is at fault in the Wall Street meltdown.

“Jay clearly dominated today's debate, showing he’s the only candidate with a substantive plan for rebuilding Washington’s economy and the middle class,” said Jaime Smith, Inslee’s press secretary. “Having lived on both sides of the state, having worked jobs liked driving bulldozers and washing dishes, Jay has a deep appreciation for Washington’s workers as well as a deep understanding of our state’s economy. It showed today.”

“While McKenna is reading from a list of talking points and pandering to voters with empty promises, Jay was offering new ideas that will make Washington a leader in the innovative new economy,” Smith continued. “Today’s debate made that contrast very clear.”

What do you think? Do you think there was a debate winner? You can log in with your Facebook account or create a free Patch account to tell us in the comments.

Don’t miss updates from Patch!