CONTRA COSTA, CA — After enduring ongoing financial challenges and the first teachers strike in its history earlier this year, West Contra Costa Unified School District leaders had reason to worry about whether they could persuade voters to renew a $10.2 million parcel tax measure.
Passage of a parcel tax -- so named because it levies a fixed amount per square foot on each "parcel" of real estate in a community -- requires getting a two-thirds majority at the ballot box.
Instead, Measure V is winning comfortably with 75.3% of the vote, as of the Nov. 13 tally. (Results will be officially certified on Dec. 3.)
Across the state, school districts such as West Contra Costa have sought voters' approval for parcel tax measures to ensure a steady source of funding for a range of educational services (unlike bond measures, which typically are for new construction or renovations).
The district's elected board says Measure V will provide a renewed source of funding for programs such as science, music, career and technical education, school libraries and counseling, as well as the ability to attract and retain qualified teachers. Of the $10.2 million the measure will raise, $2 million would go to support charter schools in the district.
The victory offers a case study in how a school district can successfully get a parcel tax approved, even at a time when voters are dealing with record high gas prices and rising costs on multiple other fronts.
The parcel tax, a uniquely California invention, has its roots in the tax revolt triggered by Proposition 13, the 1978 voter initiative that makes it difficult for districts and other local governments to raise revenues via taxation. To restrict their ability to do so, the authors of Prop. 13 inserted the two-thirds majority provision into the initiative.
Because of the challenges of winning approval for a parcel tax, a relatively small number of districts even attempt to do so. As a result, only about 100 of California's nearly 1,000 districts have parcel taxes.
Of the 15 parcel tax measures California school districts placed on the June ballot, seven failed to pass.
Currently, the parcel tax in Dublin Unified, an hour's drive inland from West Contra Costa, is losing by a tiny margin (as of Nov. 10).
Measure M in Sacramento City Unified, a district riven by severe financial troubles and labor conflict, is suffering a devastating defeat, receiving just 53.9% of the vote.
The measure was the target of an unusually strong opposition campaign by business, real estate and anti-tax organizations.
The two-thirds approval threshold is a significant one for any school district, especially those serving low-income communities like West Contra Costa, where 65% of its approximately 25,000 students qualify for free and reduced-price meals. The district encompasses five towns and cities in the San Francisco Bay Area, including Richmond.
A poll of over 700 parents and other community members commissioned by the school board six months before the election showed that the tax, titled Measure V, would fall short of passage by a small margin.
Before the school board voted in July to put the parcel tax on the November ballot, board member Leslie Reckler said she had done a careful analysis of past parcel tax elections in her district. She found that with one exception, the only time district parcel taxes were approved was during presidential election years when turnout is typically far higher than in midterm or "off cycle" elections.
In fact, since 1992, five previous West Contra Costa parcel tax measures had failed when presidential candidates were not also on the ballot.
"Based on past data and performance, the outlook was not promising," said Reckler, now in her sixth year on the board.
The measure imposes a fixed rate of 7.2 cents per square foot. That means an owner of a 2,000-square-foot house pays $144. Owners of commercial buildings pay at the same rate, although those with large structures will pay far more.
The stakes were exceptionally high for the district, which, among other measures, is spending down an emergency reserve fund to erase an operating deficit. Even with the tax, the district will need to come up with additional revenue in future years.
So what accounts for West Contra Costa's success?
Union leaders said that a vigorous canvassing effort by teachers and other school staff -- involving more than 900 hours of door knocking and leaflet drops buttressed by 30,000 text messages -- made a difference.
"We showed up, we organized, and we delivered," said Francisco Ortiz, president of United Teachers of Richmond, the union representing teachers in the district.
Board member Reckler said the teachers strike may have unexpectedly contributed to Measure V's passage "by reinforcing the economic challenges that public education is experiencing, especially in our community."
Another key factor was that the turnout in last week's midterm election was almost as high as it would have been in a presidential election year.
This year, more than 80,000 voters turned out to vote for or against the measure, compared to the nearly 85,000 who voted on the parcel tax when it was last on the ballot in 2016, a presidential election year.
District officials were also restrained in what they asked voters to support, at a time when rising costs and affordability topped voters' major concerns. They took to heart the results of the survey they commissioned, which showed that raising the tax by even 1.5 cents per square foot would likely assure its defeat.
As a result, the district did not try to increase the tax, sticking with the same rate it set in 2004, the first time the parcel tax was on the ballot. They also resisted asking for a cost-of-living increase over the nine years the tax will be in effect before voters will be asked to renew it again.
And they hewed closely to what likely voters said they'd be most likely to support when they were surveyed prior to the election.
"We didn't have the luxury to take any chances," Reckler said.
Finally, there was no major opposition from business or corporate groups. The only opposition came from the Contra Costa Taxpayers Association, an anti-tax group, and a handful of business owners.
In the voter handbook, opponents argued that the district continues to "overspend," and that frequent promises to exercise more fiscal restraint have not prevented "recurrent financial instability." But they did not mount any visible campaign against the measure.
By contrast, the measure was endorsed by every major Democratic organization, which emphasized the urgency of getting voter approval.
West Contra Costa Superintendent Cheryl Cotton hailed what she called her community's "resounding commitment" to supporting its schools. Board member Demetrio Gonzalez-Hoy said the vote reflects an understanding that "investing in public education is investing in our collective future."
But the approval of the tax in West Contra Costa doesn't mean that the district is out of the financial woods.
It still must deal with the loss of funding because of declining enrollment, paying for higher compensation to staff following the teachers strike and rising costs of necessities ranging from utilities and insurance to special education.
"Our community showed up for our schools," said union leader and West Contra Costa teacher Ortiz. "Now we have to deliver schools that are worthy of that commitment."
By Louis Freedberg, EdSource
Copyright © 2026 Bay City News, Inc. All rights reserved.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Concord Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.