CONTRA COSTA, CA — Contra Costa supervisors unanimously authorized subpoenas for Assessor Gus Kramer and his employees Tuesday after county officials said missing records and limited access to staff was stalling an independent financial audit.
Kramer threatened to challenge the subpoenas in court and asked supervisors to wait for state guidance on releasing confidential property records.
County Administrator Monica Nino said auditors could not finish their work without additional documents and individual employee interviews.
Kramer asked for time to let the State Board of Equalization determine whether outside contractors could examine confidential information in property owners' files.
"If they say I can do it, then I'll do it," Kramer said.
The FBI is investigating suspected wire fraud and other possible offenses involving Kramer's office. Agents raided the assessor's office and two Martinez residences in June.
7:49 AM
Supervisors authorized the subpoenas and directed county counsel to contact the state board. They agreed to remove documents from the subpoenas if state guidance barred access.
Supervisor Ken Carlson moved to approve the action, and Supervisor Candace Andersen seconded it.
Nino said supervisors expanded the audit after officials identified increased risk from the federal investigation and other concerns about the assessor's operations.
Auditors will examine the accuracy and timeliness of property valuations and valuation changes from fiscal years 2021–22 through 2025–26.
Auditors need records showing how employees reached assessment decisions, documented procedures and controls, and individual staff interviews, Nino said. Despite repeated requests, she said, the office had not provided all the materials or employee access.
Kramer challenged the expanded contract and the auditors' qualifications. He argued that financial auditors lacked the appraisal expertise to review property values and said the county should have sought competing proposals when it expanded the work.
"They're not appraisers," he said.
Kramer also requested outside counsel. He argued that county attorneys could not protect his office's interests while advising supervisors, citing longstanding disagreements and their involvement in earlier proceedings against him.
Kramer said he had released information he believed the law allowed him to provide and withheld other records pending state guidance.
Kramer warned that a subpoena challenge could push the dispute past the audit deadline."You won't have anything by December 31st," he said.
Andersen questioned Kramer about delayed supplemental assessments. She said cities and special districts have concerns about when additional property tax revenue reached their books.
She said a staff member received a $15,000 supplemental tax bill three and a half years after buying a home.
Andersen said those delays burdened homeowners and complicated local governments' revenue estimates.
Kramer said state law allowed him up to four years to complete supplemental assessments.
FBI agents searched the assessor's office and two Martinez residences in June as part of an active investigation.
Federal grand jury subpoenas sought years of assessment records and communications involving Kramer, Assessor-elect Vince Robb, other employees, developers, and a refinery.
The requested records concerned the Seeno family, DeNova Homes, Martinez Refining Co., and the Carmel Pines apartment complex in Walnut Creek, according to Patch.
Tuesday's vote gave the county authority to compel records and testimony but left Kramer's confidentiality objections unresolved. Supervisors set no date for auditors to receive the outstanding material.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Concord Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.