Healdsburg
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Community Corner

SMART Offers Tree Reprieve Amid Continuing Healdsburg Station Fight

A single-track option would spare Vine Street trees as residents dispute access, safety, and ridership ahead of a final decision.

| Updated
SMART’s revised Vine Street concept would preserve the trees and winding pathway that residents feared losing, but the station’s location still divides speakers. (Courtesy of SMART )

HEALDSBURG, CA — SMART staff have offered a way to save Vine Street's trees, but the redesign left Healdsburg residents still arguing over a larger question — where passengers should step off the train.

The single-track station concept would preserve the trees and existing pathway along Vine Street while placing a boarding platform beside the West Plaza parking lot, according to staff reports to the SMART board of directors during their regular monthly meeting on Wednesday.

Subscribe

However, the meeting and staff presentations did not resolve friction over whether Vine Street, or the Hudson Street Depot, should be the site of Healdburg's SMART station.

The Trees

A new Vine Street design addressed tree removal, one of the debate's most persistent objections to a downtown site and reasons for putting a station at the Hudson Street location.

An earlier Vine station design placed a center platform between two tracks and required removing all the trees along that block, dozens of which each have a ribbon tied around their trunk.

The revised concept uses one track and a side platform, preserving more of the trees and meandering pathway along Vine Street. Two tracks at the station's depot would allow trains to pass or provide space to hold a train.

Staff also showed approximately 22 parking spaces behind the proposed platform. A broader concept included bicycle parking and a plaza-style sidewalk, although some improvements would require access to city property.

The redesign would not eliminate all tree removal.

Residents welcomed the tree-saving option without agreeing on the station.

Years of planning

Depot/Hudson supporters Doug Kerr and Carolyn Brenner emphasized access for Ward Street residents, students, and river visitors, along with years of planning around the site.

"We have been planning around Hudson for 20 years, and we have to live with the drawbacks," Brenner said.

Vine Street supporters Sarah Pittenger and Karen Newberger cited safer waiting areas for teenagers and shorter walks for seniors, while downtown business owner Jim Hyde argued that the location would strengthen businesses and access to jobs.

Depot supporter Mark McMullen urged directors to delay the decision until staff provided clearer comparisons of parking, walking routes, environmental requirements, flooding, and future development.

"All it tells you is what people prefer," he said of public feedback. "It doesn't tell you which site actually works better.

Board of Director David Rabbitt rejected a delay, calling the idea "ridiculous."

Unanswered questions

SMART board member Victoria Fleming said restaurant and hospitality workers need service late enough to return home after their shifts.

If workers' needs help determine the station location, Fleming said, SMART must also plan service they can use in both directions.

SMART director Patty Garberini said the number of cars the project could remove from the road would guide her decision.

Garberini requested more information about potential riders leaving Healdsburg.

She aid parking was fuller at Vine Street than at the Depot. But she also questioned the depot's condition.

"The rehab of the Depot Station, which looks like—I don't want to say bomb shelter, but it's going to require a lot of work," Garberini said. "It's not something to really hug and embrace."

Garberini asked for estimates of riders leaving Healdsburg as well as those arriving because there's a "yin and yang."

Ariel Kelly welcomed the single-track alternative as evidence that SMART had responded to residents' concerns about trees.

Kelly also acknowledged frustration over unanswered questions, including how many passengers would use a station in a city SMART does not yet serve.

The board chair, Chris Coursey, asked staff to clarify conflicting public claims about commuting patterns.

SMART's survey is available until Nov. 30.

Staff plans to present the outreach and survey results to the Healdsburg City Council on Dec. 7, then return to the SMART board with the results ahead of an anticipated location recommendation by the board on Dec. 16.

SMART figures at a glance

Staff compared the two station sites for the board during a meeting that drew competing accounts of walking distances, neighborhood needs, downtown business prospects, and passenger safety.

  • Track configuration: Basic station construction costs would be generally similar, staff said, but provided no totals. Vine's single-track alternative would preserve trees and the pathway, with double-track capacity at Depot for passing or storage. SMART does not plan to fund an additional shuttle.
  • Jobs and residents: Vine Street's quarter-mile walking area includes 485 jobs and 510 residents. Depot Hudson's includes 264 jobs and 625 residents. Two additional Ward Street census blocks would add 19 jobs and 90 residents to Depot's figures.
  • Trip activity: Staff counted 13,300 daily trips in the area exclusive to Vine, 9,200 around Depot, and 29,000 in their shared area. Those figures describe travel activity, not projected train boardings.
  • Access: Vine offers closer Route 60 connections. Route 67 could serve either site, although rerouting to Depot could lengthen trips. Both proposals include ADA-compliant station access. The planned Ward Street crossing requires state approval.
  • Parking: Staff estimated demand at 30 spaces. Depot has 48 existing spaces. Vine would use West Plaza parking. Construction would remove some spaces regardless of station choice
More from Healdsburg
See more on Patch >

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information