LONG BEACH, CA — The White House has warned Rep. Robert Garcia, the former Long Beach mayor poised to lead one of Congress' most powerful investigative committees, that Democratic investigations into President Donald Trump's administration could cross the line into criminal conduct.
The warning, delivered in a three-page letter dated Monday from White House counsel Will Scharf, comes as Democrats prepare to take control of the House in January and launch investigations into the administration's conduct. Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, rejected the warning, accusing the White House of attempting to intimidate lawmakers before they assume control of the chamber.
Scharf accused Democrats of preparing to use congressional investigations to harass administration officials rather than pursue legitimate legislative objectives, according to the New York Times. The letter, first reported by Punchbowl News, warned that threats against executive branch officials or subpoenas intended to intimidate individuals could exceed Congress' constitutional authority.
Scharf wrote that certain conduct "may cross the line into blatant criminality," adding that unlawful subpoenas intended to deprive individuals of constitutional rights could warrant further investigation.
Garcia, who served as Long Beach mayor from 2014 to 2022 before winning election to Congress, responded defiantly, arguing that congressional oversight is a constitutional responsibility that does not require presidential approval.
"It appears Donald Trump has something to hide," Garcia said in a statement reported by the Los Angeles Times.
"Congress has wide latitude to conduct investigations and oversight, an authority inherent in the power to legislate," he added.
Garcia also accused the administration of attempting to undermine the separation of powers.
"We are a coequal branch of government and will not be deterred by baseless threats from a weaponized D.O.J. or from the president's lawyers," he said.
The confrontation follows Garcia's post-election warning that Trump administration officials should "lawyer up" as Democrats prepare to exercise their newly won investigative authority. Democrats are preparing inquiries into several aspects of the administration, including its handling of the Jeffrey Epstein investigation, immigration enforcement, Trump's business interests and financial dealings involving members of his family, according to the Associated Press.
The White House has maintained that congressional investigations must serve legitimate legislative purposes and cannot be used simply to harass or intimidate government officials.
The dispute raises questions about the limits of congressional investigative authority and the protections afforded to lawmakers under the Constitution. Congress has broad powers to investigate matters connected to legislation and government accountability, although courts have established limits on subpoenas that lack a legitimate legislative purpose.
The Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause also provides significant protections against criminal prosecution for lawmakers performing legitimate legislative duties. Legal experts interviewed by the New York Times questioned whether the administration could establish a valid criminal basis for investigating lawmakers over their official oversight activities.
Attorney General Todd Blanche, meanwhile, has acknowledged Congress' authority to conduct oversight, despite separately suggesting that threatening rhetoric by lawmakers could warrant investigation.
"Congress has oversight authority. It always has, it always will," Blanche said during remarks reported by the Associated Press.
The confrontation recalls disputes during Trump's first presidency, when his administration resisted congressional subpoenas and several battles over access to government information ultimately reached federal courts.
For Garcia, the warning marks an early confrontation over the investigative authority he is preparing to inherit. If he becomes chairman in January, the former Long Beach mayor will find himself at the center of a potentially prolonged battle between the White House and a Democratic-controlled Congress over the scope of presidential accountability.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Long Beach Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.