A missing police report doesn't necessarily prevent a California driver from filing an insurance claim. But it can make the evidence you preserve after the crash much more important.
You get into a car accident in Los Angeles and call the police.
Maybe officers don't respond. Maybe they arrive, but no formal collision report is prepared. Or maybe both drivers exchange information and leave the scene believing they can sort everything out through insurance.
Then the stories start to change.
The other driver says you caused the crash. An insurance adjuster asks for documentation. And suddenly, the fact that there is no police report feels like a much bigger problem.
Fortunately, a police report is not the only evidence that can be used to investigate a California car accident claim.
Police reports can be useful because they may document information about the collision shortly after it happened. But an insurance claim does not automatically depend on having one.
When there is no report, other evidence can become especially important in establishing how the accident happened and documenting the resulting injuries and losses.
That evidence may include photographs, video, witness statements, vehicle damage, communications between the drivers, medical records, and other documentation created after the collision.
The important part is preserving that evidence before it disappears.
If you don't have a police report, start with whatever documentation you do have.
Photos taken at the scene may show much more than a damaged bumper. They can document where the vehicles came to rest, skid marks or debris, traffic signals, lane markings, weather and road conditions, and the surrounding area.
Save the original files if possible rather than relying only on images uploaded to social media or sent through a messaging app.
You should also preserve:
If you took photos immediately after the crash, don't delete the ones that seem unimportant. Something in the background may later become relevant.
Some of the most useful evidence after a collision may also be the easiest to lose.
A nearby business, apartment building, parking garage, home, or intersection may have a camera pointed toward the roadway. But surveillance systems do not necessarily keep footage indefinitely.
The same problem applies to physical evidence.
Vehicles are repaired or salvaged. Debris is cleared. Skid marks disappear. Witnesses become difficult to locate. Memories become less precise.
That's why documenting an accident early can matter even when everyone initially agrees about what happened.
This is one reason people worry so much about not having a police report.
At the scene, a driver might apologize or acknowledge what happened. Later, their version of the collision may be different.
Without a police report, that does not automatically turn the case into one person's word against another's.
Photos, video, independent witnesses, vehicle damage, electronic communications, and other evidence may help investigators evaluate how the collision occurred.
Vehicle damage can be particularly useful in reconstructing an accident, but damage alone does not necessarily establish which driver was legally at fault. It should be considered along with the rest of the available evidence.
There is another important distinction.
Not having a police report does not necessarily mean a driver has no obligation to report the accident elsewhere.
California has separate reporting requirements that may apply depending on whether someone was injured or killed and the amount of property damage involved.
Drivers should not assume that because police did not respond or prepare a collision report, there is nothing else they need to do.
If the accident has already happened and you don't have a police report, focus on preserving the evidence that still exists.
Write down what you remember about the collision while the details are fresh. Organize your photographs and communications. Save witness information. Preserve dashcam footage. If nearby businesses or properties may have captured the collision, identify them as soon as possible.
And if you were injured, keep records related to your medical treatment and how the accident has affected your ability to work and carry out your normal activities.
A missing police report can make a disputed accident more difficult to investigate, but it does not automatically prevent an injured person from pursuing an insurance claim.
El Dabe Ritter Trial Lawyers has published a more detailed guide answering "Can You File a Car Accident Claim Without a Police Report in California?" with additional information about evidence, insurance claims, and what California drivers can do after a crash.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Los Angeles Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.