Orange County Rejects Recall By Narrow Margin: Report

ORANGE COUNTY, CA — Gov. Gavin Newsom headed back to work Wednesday after receiving an overwhelming vote of confidence from the state's voters in the attempt to recall him.

The recall effort gained traction as frustration grew over Newsom's handling of the pandemic. The intensifying recall effort dominated headlines for months and sent the governor back on the campaign trail before his term expires in 2022. It is estimated the recall would cost Orange County, and all California counties $215 million in voting-related expenses.

The "no" votes topped the "yes" votes 63.9 percent-36.1 percent Wednesday morning, with 100 percent of the state's precincts reporting, according to figures released by the Secretary of State's Office.

In one of the closest county elections, Orange County's rejected the recall, with 52.59 percent of voters voting "no" or 464,164 votes. Close behind, Orange County's approval of the recall was at 47.41 percent. The "yes" to the recall votes totaled 418,362.

In Orange County, there were a total of 885,145 ballots cast both in person and by mail in the recall election. Of those votes, 129,847 Orange County residents headed to the polls to cast their ballots, while 755,298 voters dropped them into the mail. All of the county's 1,801 precincts have fully reported and ballots are being counted. The Orange County election results are unofficial as of Wednesday. Statewide, the final results from the recall election are expected to be released on October 22, according to the

Voter turnout was just under half of the county's registered voters, at 49 percent of the county's 1.8 million voters, according to the Orange County Registrar of Voters Neal Kelley.

Orange County voters were introduced to dozens of gubernatorial hopefuls, with only a handful of Republicans and perhaps one Democrat making any impression.

Of those who voted for the recall, conservative Republican talk show host, candidate Larry Elder, received 57.63 percent of Orange County's vote, followed by democratic candidate Kevin Faffrath with 8.06 percent and former San Diego Mayor, Republican Kevin Faulconer, with 7.98 percent.

Every major network and news organization called the race less than an hour after polls closed at 8 p.m. Tuesday.

Total voter turnout was 9,176,526 statewide, or 41.6 percent of the state's total of more than 22 million registered voters. The "no" votes totaled 5,840,283, the yes votes 3,297,145.

Newsom, appearing weary from weeks of intense campaigning, spoke to supporters in Sacramento on Tuesday night and claimed victory, saying the resounding "no" vote was in support of democratic and progressive ideals and a rejection of cynical divisions.

"I want to focus on what we said yes to as a state," Newsom said. "We said yes to science. We said yes to vaccines. We said yes to ending this pandemic. We said yes to people's right to vote without fear of fake fraud or voter suppression. We said yes to women's fundamental constitutional right to decide for herself what she does with her body, her fate and her future.

"We said yes to diversity. We said yes to inclusion. ... We said yes to all those things that we hold dear as Californians, and I would argue as Americans -- economic justice, social justice, racial justice, environmental justice. ... All of those things were on the ballot this evening and so I'm humbled and grateful to the millions and millions of Californians who exercised their fundamental right to vote and expressed themselves so overwhelmingly by rejecting the division, by rejecting the cynicism."

He added: "Tonight, I am humbled, grateful, but resolved in the spirit of my political hero Robert Kennedy to make more gentle the life of this world."

The recall ballot contained only two questions: should Newsom be recalled -- removed -- from office, and if so, which of the 46 candidates on the ballot or seven write-in candidates should replace him?

Newsom needed 50% or more voters to respond "no" to the first question to remain in office. With Newsom convincingly passing that mark, the second question was quickly deemed irrelevant.

Had things gone differently, Republican talk-show host Larry Elder would have claimed the governor's office. Elder drew 46.9% of the vote in the field of 46 replacement candidates, with Democrat Kevin Paffrath a distant second at 9.8% and Republican former San Diego Mayor Kevin Faulconer in third with 8.6%.

Faulconer, speaking before any results were in, positioned the recall as "a referendum on Gavin Newsom's failure," saying, "That's why so many Californians not only signed the recall petition, but that's why Californians in all parts of the state, all party registrations, are ready for a change at the top."

But he quickly conceded defeat Tuesday night.

"It's clear that our work in California is not finished," he told supporters. "This recall showed that if you keep the focus on Gavin Newsom, he can be beat ... the focus of this election turned into national politics and personalities."

Elder, not quick to concede, finally took the stage at his campaign-night party in Costa Mesa at 10 p.m. and admitted defeat to an unhappy crowd gathered in his support.

"Let's be gracious in defeat," Elder told the crowd. "We may have lost the battle but we are going to win the war."

He again rattled off criticisms of Newsom's leadership, citing rising crime, rampant homelessness and lagging education.

Another prominent Republican in the race, businessman John Cox -- who finished fifth at 4.4% -- conceded defeat early but told supporters Tuesday night the fight to gain control of the state is not over.

"I'm a CPA. I'm a businessman," he said. "I'm horrified at the waste, the corruption, the mismanagement of this state. I'm still hopeful that I'll get a chance to manage this government and turn it around. A message has been sent to the majority party. This battle has just begun."On

Monday night, President Joe Biden visited Southern California to urge voters to reject the recall, citing Newsom's record on the coronavirus pandemic, women's rights, climate change and minimum wage.

"We need science. We need courage, we need leadership. We need Gavin Newsom," Biden said during an approximately 15-minute address at Long Beach City College.

"A governor who follows science, who's got the courage to do what's right."

Biden sought to tie supporters of the recall to former President Donald Trump, who is tremendously unpopular in California.

"You either keep Gavin Newsom as your governor or you get Donald Trump," Biden told the crowd of approximately 1,100, including Sen. Alex Padilla, D-California, Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti and Los Angeles County Supervisors Janice Hahn and Hilda Solis.

"The choice should be absolutely clear. Gavin Newsom. You have a governor who has the courage to lead."

Elder had dismissed the presidential support for the governor.

"If Gavin Newsom thinks that flying in Joe Biden and Kamala Harris -- not exactly the most admired government officials at the present time -- will make him look better, that's all you need to know about how oblivious and detached Newsom is from a large majority of Californians," Elder tweeted last week.

During a Monday morning appearance in Monterey Park, Elder repeated many of the recall's themes -- criticism of Newsom's handling of issues such as homelessness, crime and the COVID-19 pandemic, accusing him of "ignoring science" in the imposition of business and school closures.

Elder also shot back at recall critics who have labeled it a "Republican" movement.

"There are 2 million people that signed that petition," Elder said. "A good quarter of them to a third of them were the people who voted for him just two years earlier. I'm talking about independents and Democrats. Sixty- three percent of Hispanics voted for him two years ago. Now the majority of Hispanics want him out."

Elder is an outspoken opponent of government mandates -- such as those requiring mask-wearing or receiving COVID vaccines -- and had vowed to eliminate them immediately if elected.
Democratic National Committee Chairman Jaime Harrison issued a statement Tuesday night calling the vote an overwhelming victory for the party's agenda.

"Once again, voters rejected the Republican Party's denial of the pandemic sweeping our country and their subsequent refusal to address it, rejected Republicans' disproved theories about our elections and rejected Republicans' unwavering loyalty to the man who caused it all -- Donald Trump," Harrison said.

From afar, Trump had repeated his refrain of questioning the integrity of the recall election, suggesting without any evidence that the race was rigged -- just as he did before and after he lost his presidential re-election bid to Biden.

In recent days, Elder picked up on that theme. His campaign posted a link to an online election-fraud reporting website and the candidate himself refusing to say whether he would accept the election results.

With the victory, Newsom avoided the fate of former California Gov. Gray Davis, who was removed from office by recall in 2003. Actor Arnold Schwarzenegger replaced him.

City News Service, Patch Editor Ashley Ludwig contributed to this report.