Palm Desert
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Crime & Safety

Murder Trial For Indio Man Appears To Involve Longstanding Domestic Disputes

Miguel Mejia Cazarez, 44, allegedly gunned down 39-year-old Jose Luis Villegas III of Mecca in 2021.

INDIO, CA — An Indio man "instigated" a fatal confrontation targeting a longtime acquaintance over apparent conflicts connected to a woman, a prosecutor said Monday, while the defense argued the shooting was a direct result of "fear" and the desire for self-preservation.

Miguel Mejia Cazarez, 44, allegedly gunned down 39-year-old Jose Luis Villegas III of Mecca in 2021. Cazarez is charged with first-degree murder, hit-and-run resulting in property damage and sentencing-enhancing gun and great bodily injury allegations.

Subscribe

In her closing statement Monday at Cazarez's trial at the Larson Justice Center in Indio, Riverside County Deputy District Attorney Jennifer Stevenson said Cazarez was bent on doing harm to Villegas.

"This case is about revenge," the prosecutor told jurors. "He wanted revenge for all the perceived wrongs."

Stevenson said the entire chain of events on Jan. 12, 2021, can be traced to "choice after choice after choice" that Cazarez made, culminating in the deadly shooting.

"Self-defense does not apply in this case," she said. "He initiated a confrontation."

The prosecutor referred to the defendant as "an instigator (who perpetrated) an execution."

"This defendant chose to ram his car into the parked vehicles at the house where his (own) kids are," Stevenson told the jury, describing the scenario that unfolded that January afternoon on Sonora Avenue in Indio.

The prosecutor said Cazarez intentionally drove his Ford F-150 pickup into the two sedans parked out front, belonging to Monica and Jose Villegas.

Both the Toyota Corolla and Volkswagen Jetta were damaged, though the latter was still drivable. Jose Villegas immediately went out and jumped into the latter car, giving chase as Cazarez sped away, according to the prosecution.

The victim pursued Cazarez back to his residence on Ocotillo Avenue, where Villegas confronted the defendant, who pulled a handgun and opened fire with a semiautomatic pistol, the prosecutor said.

The victim managed to travel about a block before passing out and losing control, plowing into the front gate of a business at 82025 Avenue 44. An employee called the Indio Police Department, whose officers arrived a short time later. The victim was taken to a Coachella Valley trauma center, where he died that night.

"He struck that Corolla and Jetta to provoke Villegas, then drove home, still angry, and anticipated the victim might follow him," Stevenson said, asserting that Cazarez's every action pointed to premeditation.

Defense attorney Shaun Sullivan acknowledged that Cazarez and Villegas "had issues ... for decades."

Sullivan told jurors there was no reason to deny Cazarez intentionally rammed the two vehicles.

"Find him guilty of that. I won't waste your time," the attorney said.

However, he challenged the prosecution's contention of premeditation, countering that if the defendant truly wanted to take Villegas' life, "then why leave" the house after ramming the cars?

"Why not stay until (Villegas) comes out and shoot him then?" Sullivan wondered.

The defense was not specific as to what prompted the hit-and-run, saying only that it was the day of a custody exchange involving Cazarez's and Monica Villegas' children, who were with her brother.

"He's a loving and devoted father," Sullivan said of his client. "His relationship with his ex, Monica, wasn't always great."

At the outset of the trial, the attorney characterized Cazarez as the vulnerable one, asserting his client had been the target of repeated acts of alleged intimidation by Villegas. The reasons weren't specified.

Cazarez reacted by purchasing a handgun.

Sullivan said his client fled to his parents' home after hitting the cars, knowing that when he heard a vehicle's "screeching tires" coming around the corner, it was Villegas.

"Fear has a memory," the attorney said. "My client sees Jose reaching for something, and he shoots. He's not thinking; he's panicking."

He maintained the confrontation wasn't about baiting Villegas to another location to perpetrate a murder, but rather an act of "self-defense."

```It's about fear and survival," the attorney said.

Cazarez was taken into custody without incident.

He's being held in lieu of $1 million bail at the nearby Benoit Detention Center. He has no documented prior felony convictions in Riverside County.

More from Palm Desert
News | 21h
News | 1d
News | 3d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Palm Desert Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information