Petaluma
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Politics & Government

Senate Deal To Speed Energy Permits And Data Centers Sparks Outcry

Tribal leaders warn BAAJA would weaken safeguards as senators advance legislation promising faster energy development.

CALIFORNIA — A sweeping Senate bill could speed up construction of data centers, ICE detention facilities, and other controversial projects while weakening protections for sacred places. It would also limit courts' power to stop construction over legal violations, opponents warned today.

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, or BAAJA, promises faster energy development.

Subscribe

Senators from both parties want to shorten federal approval timelines for energy and infrastructure projects.

Their push comes as Trump promises to temper his opposition to wind and solar power, following nearly two years of offshore project restrictions, renewable energy subsidy cuts, and support for oil and gas expansion.

The bill could reach the House floor in November, but Democrats may postpone negotiations until they assume control of Congress and can demand stronger terms.

They want to ensure Trump will keep his renewable energy promises. Republicans, meanwhile, may reconsider their support after voters pushed several prominent data center supporters out of office.

Those defeats could strengthen calls to curb construction and preserve community participation in project reviews.

Tribal leaders, state officials, and conservation advocates said today that the bill's provisions would weaken their ability to protect water, public lands, and cultural sites.

In addition to easing development of data centers on public lands, the bill would ease approvals for offshore drilling and mining projects.

"This bill is an affront to Tribal sovereignty," Bennae Calac, interim executive director of the Chuckwalla National Monument Intertribal Commission, said in a statement.

"Tribes do not bottleneck progress. If anything, consultation with Tribes helps ensure development is done in a proper manner and is cost-effective."

Senators advanced BAAJA in a 65–31 procedural vote on Wednesday, clearing a major hurdle toward passage, The Hill reported.

Supporters say they want to accelerate construction of transmission lines that connect renewable energy to customers, reduce permitting delays, and protect approved projects against presidential reversals.

"BAAJA still needs some adjustments and clarifications, but it ought to be voted on this Congress," Rep. Scott Peters, D-San Diego, said in an October 22 statement.

Peters supports passing BAAJA with adjustments, arguing it would accelerate infrastructure development, lower costs, create jobs, and protect ratepayers from data center expenses.

The bill also seeks to make large data centers cover electricity costs associated with their demand.

Peters separately opposes the proposed NAVWAR data center in San Diego.

Cleantech San Diego President and CEO Jason Anderson said the bill would give developers greater certainty that permits will remain valid.

The measure still faces amendments and a final Senate vote before House consideration.

Opponents warn that BAAJA would ease development of pipelines and other projects, including data centers, as cities pause approvals to assess environmental impacts.

At least 10 Bay Area cities—Brisbane, Fairfield, Gilroy, Hayward, Oakland, Oakley, Pittsburg, Richmond, San Francisco, and San Jose—have adopted temporary pauses on new data center approvals while officials consider development rules and environmental impacts.

Some California legislators are urging legislators to reject the bill.

"We don't have to swallow this terrible deal," Rep. Jared Huffman, D-Calif., said Thursday.

He also challenged claims that Congress would lose its only opportunity to overhaul permitting if lawmakers delayed the bill.

Congress can negotiate permitting changes without accepting BAAJA's current terms, he said on Instagram.

Huffman pledged to pursue changes during the next Congress if lawmakers could not secure them now.

"We can produce a better deal," he said.

In a November 9 letter, California Attorney General Rob Bonta and fellow attorneys general urged Senate leaders to delay a vote.

They acknowledged that an amendment restores mandatory consultation under the National Historic Preservation Act but warned that agencies could still make key decisions without state or tribal input and disregard adverse effects when other considerations outweigh them.

The letter also warned that courts could not issue a preliminary injunction solely for a violation of the National Historic Preservation Act, even when a historic property faced imminent destruction.

Similar restrictions would apply to violations of the National Environmental Policy Act.

The bill risks turning review into wasteful box-checking exercises rather than meaningful safeguards for environmental, historic, and cultural resources, according to the letter.

The officials also challenged changes to the Clean Water Act. They said BAAJA would narrow the impacts states could consider when reviewing federally permitted projects and impose new hurdles on water-quality conditions.

Calac said the consequences would reach beyond administrative deadlines.

"Frankly, it would exclude us from the rooms where decisions are made. I urge our Senators to reject it."

Data center proposals have intensified the fight over public lands.

The Center for Western Priorities identified at least 17 apparent applications for data center campuses in Bureau of Land Management records, alongside applications for supporting infrastructure. Some applications overlap and may represent fewer distinct projects, the organization reported.

"We should all be very, very worried about this bill and what it would mean for the development of data centers on public lands," Krystian Lahage, public policy officer for the Mojave Desert Land Trust, said.

Shannon Olivieri Hovis, chief strategy officer for California Environmental Voters, compared the legislation with California's recently defeated Proposition 45.

"BAAJA asks Congress to make that same tradeoff for the entire country," Hovis said in a news release. "Following an election in which voters resoundingly rejected Trump's polluters-over-people agenda, the Senate should slow down, listen to voters, and get this right."

The promise of faster construction has divided clean energy advocates. Supporters expect transmission improvements to help renewables reach the grid.

Critics fear the bill would entrench fossil fuel projects and weaken protections that Congress may struggle to restore, TIME reported.

A separate federal review released Wednesday underscores unresolved questions about data center oversight.

The Government Accountability Office assessed whether 21 federal agencies with data centers met federal requirements for managing and operating data centers.

The GAO looked at agency oversight, automated monitoring, energy and water use, operational reliability, and cybersecurity and physical security.

None of the 21 agencies in the study with data centers had fully addressed the five criteria, the GAO reported in the review.

More from Petaluma
News | 2d
News | 2d
News | 3d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Petaluma Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information