Restaurants & Bars
'Naughty Or Spice' Holiday Punch: A Patch Recipe Share
Spice up your festivities & dazzle guests with this spicy cocktail, featuring hints of orange, lemon, almonds and ... bourbon.

SAN DIEGO, CA — If you're looking to — literally — punch up your holiday party this year, Patch has you covered.
This "Naughty or Nice" punch recipe, courtesy of Punch Bowl Social, a chain of fun-loving eateries with bowling, karaoke and shuffleboard, could be your event's signature cocktail. So grab your punch bowl (or borrow your mom's), and follow along.
This festive cocktail includes Old Forester Bourbon, Monin Orgeat (premium almond syrup), house-made spiced orange syrup, St. Elizabeth Allspice and fresh lemon juice, garnished with oranges and cloves.
Find out what's happening in San Diegofor free with the latest updates from Patch.
In California, Punch Bowl Social locations are in San Diego and Sacramento, where this specialty drink will be on the menu through Dec. 29.
NOTE: While the recipes may call for specific brands of alcohol, any substitute brand may be used.
Find out what's happening in San Diegofor free with the latest updates from Patch.
--------------
“Naughty or Spice”
Single Serving
- 2 oz Old Forester Bourbon
- 0.75 oz Monin Ogreat
- 0.5 oz spiced orange syrup* (see below)
- 0.25 oz St. Elizabeth Allspice
- 0.75 oz Fresh Lemon Juice
4 Servings
- 8 oz Old Forester Bourbon
- 3 oz Monin Ogreat
- 2 oz spiced orange syrup* (see below)
- 1 oz St. Elizabeth Allspice
- 3 oz Fresh Lemon Juice
8 Servings
- 16 oz Old Forester Bourbon
- 6 oz Monin Ogreat
- 4 oz spiced orange syrup* (see below)
- 2 oz St. Elizabeth Allspice
- 6 oz Fresh Lemon Juice
Directions:
Mix all ingredients in a tin, add ice, shake vigorously for 7 seconds, strain into a bunch bowl, add ice & garnish, enjoy!
Spiced Orange Syrup: *Juice 12 oranges (adjust for 1, 4 or 8 servings) add to saucepan. Quarter additional 12 oranges, hand squeeze juice from quarters into a saucepan, drop remaining quarters with rind into pan. Add 1 liter water, 1 TBSP nutmeg, 1 TBSP cinnamon - boil on low until rinds are very tender, at least 10 minutes. Strain through cheesecloth and add equal parts sugar to liquid and stir until dissolved.
----------------------
FOR MORE FROM THE PATCH RECIPE FILES:
- Holiday Cocktail Recipes To Make The Season Merry & Bright
- Taco Bell Hotel's Fire Chip Chilaquiles
- Green Cilantro Goddess Ravioli
- Mama Milia's 'Best Guacamole Ever'
- Tequila Salute: Grapefruit & Rosemary Margarita Recipe
- Avocado-Lover Alert: Chef Shares 2 Tasty Recipes
- California Pastry Chef's Coveted Strawberry Almond Cupcake Recipe
- Chef Shares Recipe For Popular 'Guacamole Nogada'
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.