Federal Judge Rules San Carlos Cops "Acted Illegally"

U.S. District Judge Jeffrey White ruled Friday that two San Carlos police officers "acted illegally" after they barged into the home of Bruce Hopkins, whom they suspected had been drinking and driving after his involvement in a minor car accident more than seven years ago.

"This was a decision I had been anticipating, but one I fear will bring about more appeals and more years of this lawsuit," said Hopkins' lawyer Anthony Boskovich, who has an office in Redwood City.

"These officers were wrong, and the judge saw that," he continued.

Boskovich said Hopkins is living with friend in West Virginia, and while he is aware of the national attention his lawsuit has received, Boskovich insists Hopkins is "oblivious."

"He was curled up in the fetal position when those two officers barged into his home," said Boskovich in an interview. "He is traumatized."

On a calm mid-August day in 2003, Hopkins was involved in a minor traffic accident. The driver of the car Hopkins hit followed him home and called the San Carlos police and told them she smelled alcohol on Hopkins' breath, according to court records.

The officers, Armand Bonvincino and David Buelow, spoke with the woman and then proceeded to knock on Hopkins' door. Hopkins was living with his aunt at the time, who has sinced passed away.

After receiving no response, the officers barged into the home, down the stairs, with guns drawn, according to records. They found Hopkins in the fetal position and made an arrest. 

A San Mateo County judge later dismissed driving under the influence charges against Hopkins. Hopkins then countersued the officers for damages, claimng they acted illegally and entered his home without a warrant. 

"We'll see if this is the end," Boskovich said. "We'll wait to see if they appeal."