San Clemente Couple Convicted in $3 Million Fraud Case

SAN CLEMENTE, CA — A businessman and his then-CPA wife were convicted today of defrauding investors and stealing more than $3 million in an affinity scheme.

"Steven Andrew McKinlay, 59, and Kristi B. McKinlay, 57, both of Coto de Caza, pleaded guilty to a court offer over the People’s objection to 48 felony counts of using untrue statements in the purchase or sale of a security, 14 felony counts of selling a security in an issuer transaction without qualification, one felony count of grand theft, and one felony count of the use of a device in a scheme to defraud, and sentencing enhancement allegations for loss over $100,000, aggravated white collar crime over $100,000, aggravated white collar crime over $500,000, and causing property damage with loss over $3.2 million," the Orange County District Attorney stated today.

Steven McKinlay was sentenced to five years in state prison.

Co-defendant Kristi McKinlay faces a sentence of one year in county jail and 10 years of formal probation at her sentencing on Dec. 13, 2016, at 8:30 a.m. in Department C-49, Central Justice Center, Santa Ana.

The defendants victimized 15 individuals, including a former Major League Baseball player, a family friend who came into money through a devastating personal injury, and a cancer patient who wanted to secure an inheritance for his family.

Their investments ranged from $22,500 to over $700,000. Many of the victims had been associated with the defendants through the church they attended.

What is an Affinity Scam?

Many affinity scams involve "Ponzi" or pyramid schemes, where new investor money is used to make payments to earlier investors to give the false illusion that the investment is successful.

"This ploy is used to trick new investors to invest in the scheme and to lull existing investors into believing their investments are safe and secure. In reality, the fraudster almost always steals investor money for personal use," OCDA spokesperson Roxi Fyad said. "Both types of schemes depend on an unending supply of new investors - when the inevitable occurs, and the supply of investors dries up, the whole scheme collapses and investors discover that most or all of their money is gone."

At the time of the thefts, Steven and Kristi McKinlay were owners of God’s Sports Company (GSC).

Between Aug. 13, 2011, and June 27, 2015, Steven and Kristi McKinlay defrauded more than $3 million from more than 10 clients by convincing them to invest in GSC without disclosing material facts, including prior bankruptcy filings by Steven McKinlay and outstanding liens against the defendants, using investor funds to pay back some of the other investors in a “Ponzi” scheme, and using investor money for personal use. The defendants spent investors’ money on $10,000 a month rent for a San Clemente home and $7,000 a month rent for a Coto de Caza home, paying for their daughter’s wedding, purchasing a luxury suite at Angel Stadium of Anaheim, purchasing cars, and paying off old debts and day-to-day expenses. They used investors’ money to donate $50,000 to their church. The defendants also put their relatives and their friends’ relatives on GSC payroll.

This case was investigated by the Orange County District Attorney (OCDA) Bureau of Investigations after receiving a complaint from a whistleblower. Several victims were unaware that their investments had been defrauded until being contacted by the OCDA during the course of the investigation. The defendants were arrested on Dec. 16, 2015, by OCDA Investigators, with the assistance of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department.

“Affinity fraud most commonly happens in church, where victims are asked to invest with a false sense of trust in an investor who preaches morals and ethics. I want to remind the public that affinity fraud can also happen with people having the same nationality, race, or are living in senior living communities,” said District Attorney Tony Rackauckas. “Nobody is exempt from affinity fraud and people should vet everyone before investing, especially those they have a lot in common with or they think they know well and can trust.”

Deputy District Attorney Michelle Lipton of the Major Fraud Unit is prosecuting this case.

Shutterstock Image