Take A Tour: Bethel's 5 Priciest Homes On The Market Right Now

BETHEL, CT — One of the largest pieces of land left in Bethel, with a farmhouse dating to 1768, tops the town's most expensive homes for sale. At just under $4 million, it's priced at more than three times the next listing on Zillow.com.

No. 1 on the list is 62 Codfish Hill Road, asking $3,999,999 for 61.43 acres of former farmland in the Codfish Hill area. The listing pitches it as both a home and a possible subdivision. The colonial farmhouse, built in 1768, has 4,416 square feet. Zillow lists six bedrooms, three full bathrooms and one half bathroom. It has a great room with a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, three stone fireplaces in all, a first-floor primary suite and a walk-out in-law suite. There's also an oversized three-bay garage and barn with a full second floor. The listing calls the property "a diamond in the rough." It has been on Zillow for 396 days.

Just behind it is a new Colonial planned near the Redding line on Aunt Pattys Lane West, listed as 37 Aunt Pattys Lane West at $1,250,000. The 3,200-square-foot plan has four bedrooms, two full bathrooms and one half bathroom. The listing says the current 6-acre parcel will be divided to create a lot of about 3 acres, and the final address hasn't been set. It has been on Zillow for 139 days.

Rounding out the top three is 58 Wolfpits Road, a 1959 ranch across the road from Bethel Land Trust woodlands, listed at $1,100,000. The price went up $550,000 on Oct. 26, and the sale now includes two adjacent lots, 60 and 62 Wolfpits, for 7.73 acres in all. The 1,574-square-foot house has three bedrooms, one full bathroom and one half bathroom. It has been on Zillow for 48 days.

No. 4 is 26 Codfish Hill Road, a 1750 house on 3.68 acres at $850,000, pitched at car collectors and woodworkers. Its post-and-beam barn by Connext Post & Beam has a car lift, workshop space and an upper loft, and there's also an oversized two-car garage. The 2,044-square-foot house has three bedrooms, two full bathrooms and one half bathroom. It has been on Zillow for 74 days.

Closing out the top five is a condo at the Villages at Timber Oak, within walking distance of downtown Bethel: 20 Penny Lane, Unit 20, listed at $790,000 after a $20,000 price cut on Oct. 10. The 3,714-square-foot unit, built in 2009 and on the market for the first time, has three bedrooms, three full bathrooms and one half bathroom. The community has tennis and pickleball courts, a heated pool and a clubhouse. It has been on Zillow for 27 days.

Prices, listing status and days on market are from each property's Zillow.com listing as of Oct. 26, 2026, and may change. Only homes marked "For sale" or offered as new construction were included; pending, coming-soon, land-only and multifamily listings were left out. A 21-acre lot on Nashville Road listed at $2.2 million was also left out.