Fairfield
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Crime & Safety

2nd Allegation Of Sexual Misconduct Made Against Former Fairfield Prep Teacher: Attorney

In October, the school settled another similar case with a victim for $1.1 million, according to attorney Mitchell Garabedian.

FAIRFIELD, CT — A second former Fairfield Prep student has alleged that he was sexually abused by a former teacher at the private boys high school more than 20 years ago.

According to the alleged victim's attorney, Mitchell Garabedian, the former student claims he was sexually abused by Melissa Laguna, also known as Melissa Goodwin, "from about 2003 to about 2005 when he was about 16 to 18 years old."

Subscribe

The identity of the former student and details of the alleged abuse were not disclosed.

In October, another former Fairfield Prep student, who alleged he was sexually abused by Laguzza/Goodwin from 2001 to 2005, settled with the school for $1.1 million, according to Garabedian.

"The sexual abuse survivors each had Ms. Laguzza as their Spanish teacher during the same year but in different classes, were close in age and were each sexually abused over 100 times for about two years by Ms. Laguzza," Garabedian said in a statement. "The sexual abuse time periods partially overlapped. The survivors were each sexually abused, for instance, in Ms. Laguzza's car at Fairfield Prep and in Ms. Laguzza's residences. Ms. Laguzza gave each child money as a gift."

In both cases, according to Garabedian, the victims were allegedly "sexually abused by Ms. Laguzza under the deceptive appearance of tutoring for educational purposes." The second victim was also allegedly abused in his parents' home, Garabedian added.

After Fairfield Prep, Laguzza/Goodwin taught at Cheshire Academy, but is no longer with that school.

"The supervisors at Fairfield Prep once again failed miserably in the supervision of Ms. Laguzza and, as a result, in the protection of innocent children," Garabedian said. "Protecting children at Fairfield Prep and at any school is a moral obligation and not just an option for those who operate the school."

In a statement, obtained by Patch, which was sent to Fairfield Prep alumni and parents, school President Christian Cashman said officials learned of the new allegations earlier this month.

"Fairfield Prep acted immediately, proactively, and transparently with all concerns brought to its attention," Cashman wrote. "In addition to notifying the appropriate state agency and local law enforcement authorities, Fairfield Prep continues to respond to prospective secondary school employers with accurate and transparent information."

Cashman continued, "Prep continues to actively review all known allegations about this past teacher through an independent investigator."

That investigator is Thomas Murphy, Esq., of Cowdery, Murphy & Healey, LLC, and the school urges anyone with relevant information to contact them.

"Due to the ongoing investigation, Fairfield Prep cannot comment further," Cashman said, adding the following statement:

Fairfield Prep is devoted to our mission of caring for the whole person and the well-being of our young men. We affirm the shared Jesuit, Catholic values of our community and underscore our commitment to our students, families and alumni.

We recognize that sexual abuse is deeply sensitive and traumatic, and that no statement can undo the pain felt by those who have experienced sexual misconduct. We take each matter seriously and pursue it thoroughly with the utmost care, compassion, and attention, both internally and in conjunction with local law enforcement.

Patch reached out to the Fairfield Police Department for comment, but did not immediately receive a reply.

More from Fairfield
News | 2h
News | 19h
News | 1d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Fairfield Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information