"New’ Darien Library Should Give New Canaan Pause

The executive director of the New Canaan Library has told us to look at Darien as the model library for New Canaan to emulate. So we did. If Darien’s experience after it built its library is anything to go by, the New Canaan Library’s planned renovation really is shaping up to be a classic boondoggle.

Some data: After Darien built its new library in 2009 in a project very similar to what the New Canaan Library is contemplating now, after the first year rush, traffic there has fallen, even as operating costs to run the new, larger LEED, Gold (which should make it extra efficient) building soared from $2.9 million in 2007 to $4.99 million in 2019.

This was all pre-coronavirus, of course, and consistent with the trend across the state.

With all due respect to our friends in Darien, that can’t be counted as a success in any way. There’s little reason to think that the New Canaan Library will have a different experience once its new building is complete.

For data and charts, please see https://tinyurl.com/y4jj2g2z

Yet the library is dead set to go ahead with its scheme. And without giving New Canaan taxpayers any significant information. Will this turn into another public/private venture like the playing fields? Who will make-up the shortfall when the building comes in over budget? And what is the budget, and what is it based on?

If the library were funded by private donations, that would be one thing. But it’s not. New Canaan taxpayers pony up 75% of the library’s operating costs every year, and pay healthcare for the employees as well as the insurance on the property and building. We need to see the New Canaan Library Board’s pro forma income statement, cash flow, and balance sheet model for the new library before we are asked to pay for it.

One thing we should take Darien’s lead on is keeping the original building. At the very least, the renovation plans should be altered so that the 1913 Landmark legacy isn’t torn down, so it can be repurposed (and it will give LEED credits!). The much-loved original 1913 building is an important link to New Canaan’s past, and the town and library would do well to honor it.