New Haven
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Crime & Safety

Video: New Haven Man, 49, Charged in Fatal Stabbing of Michael Spencer Downtown: NHPD

Following an argument with the man now charged, Spencer, 37, of New Haven, was fatally stabbed near the New Haven Green on Aug. 12.

| Updated
Carlos Marrero, 49, of New Haven, was charged with murder and carrying a dangerous weapon. (NHPD)

NEW HAVEN, CT — A 49-year-old New Haven man has been charged with murder in the daytime fatal stabbing of Michael Spencer, 37, of New Haven, across the street from the New Haven Free Public Library on Aug. 12.

It was just before 3 p.m. when cops were called to the area of Temple and Elm streets downtown for a report of two men fighting outside the library. When officers got there they found Spencer with multiple stab wounds on the street corner next to a CT Transit bus.

Subscribe

Taken to Yale-New Haven Hospital, Spencer died from his injuries.

The fight between Spencer and Carlos Marrero began inside the library, police said, and after being kicked out by library security, resumed the fight in the street, leading to "Marrero stabbing Spencer several times," police said.

The case was assigned to Detective Freddy Salmeron, of the Major Crimes Unit, working under the supervision of Sergeant Jonathan Pleckaitus. He was able to develop probable cause to arrest Marrero for the homicide.

Marrero was taken into custody on Aug. 18 on an unrelated warrant for failing to appear in court on weapons charges and is currently incarcerated.

The arrest warrant is for murder and carrying a dangerous weapon.

The bond has been set at $1,500,000.

A media briefing Wednesday at police headquarters included members of Spencer's family.

More from New Haven
News | 6h
News | 9h
News | 4h
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
New Haven Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information