Schools
3 More Books Challenged At Sarasota County Schools: District
"Choke" was removed from North Port, Venice high school libraries after review by a district administrator, Sarasota County Schools said.

SARASOTA COUNTY, FL β Three more books with coming-of-age themes that include drug or LGBTQ references recently faced removal from schools, a district administrator told the Sarasota County School Board at Tuesdayβs workshop and meeting.
A parent filed a complaint at Riverview High School about βLawn Boyβ by Jonathan Evison and βLooking for Alaskaβ by John Green, Rob Manoogian, supervisor of the districtβs instructional materials and library services department, said during an update on challenged materials at local schools.
A staff committee at Riverview reviewed βLawn Boyβ and made a recommendation about the book, he said. Though he didnβt specify the recommendation, he said the complainant was alerted about the committeeβs decision and has an opportunity to appeal.
Find out what's happening in Sarasotafor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Several members have since quit the committee and the school is in the middle of end-of-the-year testing, Manoogian said. The school will replace the outgoing members and the committee will review βLooking for Alaska.β
Related Stories:
Find out what's happening in Sarasotafor free with the latest updates from Patch.
- Embracing Our Differences Art Exhibit Vandalized - Sarasota
- After Parents Read Rape Scenes At Board Meeting Schools Remove Books
- Man Seeks Court Order To Remove 'Sexually Explicit' Books From Schools
βLawn Boyβ is a semi-autobiographical, coming-of-age novel about a biracial, young adult from a working-class family in Washington. Itβs been challenged by some schools and libraries because of profanity, sexually explicit scenes and LGBTQ+ themes, according to the American Library Association.
βLooking for Alaskaβ is another coming-of-age tale about a high school junior at a boarding school who is grappling with the death of a friend. The book has previously been challenged at other schools and libraries because of a sexually explicit scene, offensive language, and the inclusion of drugs, alcohol, and smoking, the ALA said.
Manoogian also removed βChokeβ by Chuck Palahniuk from North Port and Venice high schools after reviewing the book, circumventing the districtβs process for removing challenged materials.
The book has previously been challenged for being sexually explicit and promoting homosexuality, the Illinois Library Association said.
These were the only two copies of the book β which is about a recovering sex addict and con artist who pretends to choke for a living β in the district. Looking through the data available to Sarasota County Schools, which dates back to 2013, one copy had only been checked out once since then, while the other has never been circulated, he said.
When reviewing the title, βit was very clear to me at the onset that the book was geared for an adult audience,β he told the board. βI think itβs very important that we recognize when talking about books, and as passionate as I am about reading and our kids reading, that itβs incumbent upon us as a school district that there are materials that I think everyone would agree arenβt written for K-12 students and theyβre written for adults.β
Under new state laws, the district wouldnβt be allowed to buy copies of βChokeβ because of its themes, Manoogian said. βHad someone brought that title to us now under current law for purchasing purposes we would not have been able to purchase it, nor would we have purchased it, because it was not designed, again, or written with that (K-12) audience in mind. It was written for an adult audience.β
During the public comment segment of Tuesdayβs board meeting, a former elementary school teacher of more than 40 years called the district out for removing the book from library shelves without following the established process.
βThey say we read to know we are not alone. These books remind students they are not alone, and thatβs a comfort,β Mary Ginley said. βIt certainly was to me when I was a teenager β short, geeky, awkward, loaded with acne and not one bit cool. We also read to learn new things, to be exposed to new ideas, to understand our world. School prepares students for our complex, ever-changing world, and one way they do this is by the wide variety of books they put in our school libraries.β
She continued, βEvery time a book is removed, it further undermines the faith we have in our district staff and leadership that bought the book in the first place.β
Whatβs worse than the book being removed, is that βthe proper procedure was not followed,β Ginley said. βIf we donβt, who knows what books will disappear next week or next month.β
βI do take the process seriously, but I also take our responsibility as a board that oversees education to respect all that role,β board chair Bridget Ziegler said. βThere is a balance and we do need to protect and preserve that.β
She read a March 25 email from Manoogian during the meeting.
βI am the first one to defend the integrity of those policies, however, given the changes in legislation and vetting new titles, I believe we are within our rights to remove this titleβ considering the stateβs guidelines, he wrote, according to Ziegler.
In Manoogianβs email, he said the book was βnot age- and grade-level appropriateβ and βnot suited for student needs,β according to the chair. βThis title was clearly intended for an adult audience.β
Ziegler said she supports parents allowing their children, whether the district removes them from schools or not.
βThere are books that are not banned by the federal government, that are available on Amazon, at a public library, at Barnes & Noble that would not be appropriate here and I donβt want to infringe upon any parentsβ right to read that to their child,β she said. βBut there are going to be guardrails that we, as a board, are responsible to do when it comes to the appropriate material.β