Politics & Government

Joliet Police Officer Made $180,706 In 2018; Here's How

Joliet Patch's latest exclusive sheds light on how your city of Joliet tax dollars are being put to use.

(John Ferak, Patch staff)

JOLIET, IL — Last year, the city of Joliet's upper administration was in a state of flux. Chief of Police Brian Benton, at 49, gave his notice of retirement. Two months later, Joliet's City Council negotiated an $89,000 settlement to get rid of City Manager David Hales after less than a year at City Hall. Multiple deputy chiefs retired with buyouts in excess of $100,000, and paid leave for officers facing termination hit nearly $130,000.

Meanwhile, Joliet Police Patrolman Michael Pauly's average monthly pay was more than $15,000 for 2018.

Pauly, who joined Joliet's force in March 2004, made $180,706 in total pay from the city of Joliet last year, Joliet Patch found. Through a Freedom of Information Act request, Patch obtained a compensation breakdown to determine just how Pauly, as a blue uniform patrolman, made more money than the third-largest city of Illinois pays its police chief, deputy chiefs, fire chief, corporation counsel and virtually all other department heads across city government.

Find out what's happening in Jolietfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Pauly's regular patrolman's salary for 2018 was $104,333. And yet Pauly ended up as the 16th highest paid employee with the city; of which several of those above Pauly in the top 15 had their total compensation inflated substantially due to retiring mid-year and cashing out their fringe benefits packages.

Issues of compensation and generous fringe benefits packages have risen in recent years in the city of Joliet, notably in the police and fire departments. In June, some members of the Joliet Police Department's Supervisors Association urged the Joliet City Council to oust Marty Shanahan as interim city manager after identified several Joliet police supervisors who were in violation of their own contract by stockpiling too much unused vacation or too much comp time, or both.

Find out what's happening in Jolietfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

In 2018, Patch wrote several articles highlighting soaring costs of overtime at the Joliet Fire Department. Overtime had become a problem at the fire department for two of the three previous years.

Patch also produced several articles about the pay of Joliet Police Officer Lionel Allen, who appealed his January termination by Chief Al Roechner and retired in August. In 2018, Allen was the 20th highest paid employee, making a total of $174,614.

In Pauly's case, the overwhelming majority of his $76,373 in extra city pay came from two main categories: overtime and special assignment pay, Patch learned.

Pauly made $40,254 in overtime — $3,355 per month — with the police department in 2018. On top of that, Pauly made another $28,390 — $2,366 per month — in special assignment pay (special assignments for Joliet police officers are worked in addition to the officer's regular weekly patrols for the city.)

Between the two categories, Pauly made an extra $5,720 every month in 2018.

Additionally, Pauly received the $2,100 annual court stipend the city provides to members of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 58 as part of their current multiyear contract; Pauly also made $1,849 in actual courthouse overtime pay.

For 2018 holiday pay, Pauly made an extra $3,020. As a master police officer, Pauly also got $761 in what's known as RACE pay, the data provided by the city showed.

Overall, Pauly made $36,603 more in 2018 than he made in 2017, Joliet Patch discovered.

Last year, Pauly made $26,951 more in overtime pay than he did in 2017 and $5,614 more in special assignment pay than he did in 2017. Pauly made $144,103 with the city for 2017.

Since 2012, Officer Pauly has never made less than $142,398 as a Joliet patrolman. Back in 2012, Pauly's regular patrolman salary was $88,920.

In 2013, when Pauly's annual pay increased to $92,473, Pauly made a total of $153,094, of which $19,895 was overtime and another $36,515 was special assignment pay.

Two years later, in 2015, when Pauly's annual patrolman's salary increased to $99,239, Pauly made $163,958, of which $22,422 was overtime, plus another $33,013 was special assignment pay.

Joliet Patch visited the Joliet Police Station on Wednesday morning attempting to give Pauly a chance to comment about his overtime pay and special assignment compensation totals for 2018. But he chose not to call Patch back during the past two days.

City employees told Patch that prior to joining the police department 15 years ago, Pauly, now 47, worked on the Lockport Police Department.

In November 2018, Joliet Patch observed Pauly working in uniform on a weekend with his city of Joliet squad car stationed at the large parking lot for the Old Joliet Prison on Collins Street. That night, Chicago Hauntings was leading a group of two dozen people on guided Paranormal Tours on the inside of the limestone prison walls.

That particular night, Pauly remained around his squad car in case anybody needed his help or assistance.

In addition to obtaining Pauly's city of Joliet pay history since 2010, Joliet Patch requested the past six years of awards for Pauly and any discipline taken against him.

In May 2018, Officer Pauly received a unit merit award at the 12th annual police department. His award included certificates of congratulation from Illinois State Senators Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant and Pat McGuire as well as State Representativese Natalie Manley and Larry Walsh Jr.

Officer Michael Pauly, image via city of Joliet

Incidentally, three months earlier, in February 2018, Pauly received an oral reprimand from then-deputy chief of administration Tab Jensen.

Pauly had called a citizen a derogatory name for filing a complaint against him.

"An investigation was conducted concerning your calling the complainant a 'bitch,'" Pauly was notified in writing. "Joliet Police Department General Order 7-1 Code of Conduct, Subsection: '1.'1 "Members shall not use coarse or disrespectful language towards any citizen or fellow member nor maltreat anyone within the member's scope of authority.

"You were given notice of the decision to give you an oral reprimand. You waived your right to an administrative hearing and accepted the recommended discipline," Jensen advised Pauly.

Joliet Patch's exclusive story on Pauly's nearly $181,000 in pay comes one month after the Chicago Sun-Times published an editorial drawing attention to the excessive amounts of overtime being made by some members of the Chicago Police Department.

The headline of the Chicago Sun-Times editorial was "Getting A Handle On Overtime For Chicago Cops Is Overdue."

RELATED coverage:

(Editor's Note: Additional context and story links to other Joliet Patch articles highlighting issues of overtime pay at the Joliet Police Department and Joliet Fire Department have been added.)