Across Maine
Politics & Government

Maine's largest paper target of anonymous critic

Who's behind Substack's "Portland Press Herald Watch?"

| Updated
This post was contributed by a community member.

By Ted Cohen

An anonymous media watchdog has begun a new column shadowing the largest paper in Maine.

Subscribe

"Press Herald Watch" on Substack debuted with a searing post-election critique.

"It once punched above its weight," the secret media watcher writes. "Today it aspires to produce features that can be found in Good Housekeeping magazine. The hell with investigative journalism.

"After being beat, outclassed and clown-suited by media covering the recent Collins/Platner/Jackson race for senate, the Portland Press Herald continues its decline into irrelevance.

"Every step along the way, serious news organizations such as the Boston Globe, New York Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, Associated Press, Politico and every major broadcast station outpaced the Press Herald with exclusive Maine stories that redefined the race, thoughtful commentary that went beyond the obvious and data driven analysis that the Press Herald could not muster."

Who's behind this?

(Shutterstock.com photo)

The Substack piece surfaced three days before Poynter dropped a column focusing on the paper's failed attempt at covering the state's most-watched U.S. Senate election in modern times.

The views expressed in this post are the author's own. Want to post on Patch? Register for a user account.
More from Across Maine
News | 16h
News | 16h
News | 1d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Across Maine Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information