DANVERS, MA — The Danvers Select Board bucked a recent practice of looking to raise residential and commercial/industrial taxes proportionally as the Board voted to increase the burden on businesses — while attempting to ease increases for residents — during its annual classification vote on Tuesday night.
After a lengthy discussion, which included more public comment than in most recent years, the Select Board settled on increasing residential taxes by 2.67 percent and commercial/business taxes by 4.26 percent.
This will result in an increase of $208 annually for the average single-family homeowner and an increase of $1,844 for the average business bill.
Commercial property bills can vary widely based on the valuation of the property related to its size and location.
The average condominium tax bill will increase $84, with the average two-family bill rising by $90.
The tax shift comes as the valuation of single-family homes is rising more sharply in recent years than condos, multi-family homes and commercial properties. The tax classifications are based on the town spending that was approved at town meeting in the spring.
The 4-1 vote followed a lengthy discussion of whether the town should adhere to a proportional increase for all, or attempt to provide homeowners a break amid inflation, the new trash fee and other financial pressures.
"Everybody wants to be equal," said Select Board member Maureen Bernard, who had proposed shifting a larger increase of the burden away from residents. "However, and maybe I shouldn't say this on TV, but the majority of our commercial buildings are not Danvers residents. They don't really live here. ...
"The Danvers residents, they live here, their kids go to school here."
Select Board member Gardner Trask argued that was the very reason to keep the increase, at the very least, proportional — that taxes paid go toward municipal services, including more than half of the town budget allocated to schools, that residents benefit from and businesses do not.
Trask had proposed a 3.16 percent increase across the board, which he said would have largely maintained the two-thirds shift of funding coming from property owners compared to business owners, when three-quarters of tax-paying properties are residential and only one-quarter commercial-property owners.
The tax-burden shift is a way for cities and towns to lean the burden more heavily toward their commercial tax bases. North Shore cities like Beverly and Salem shift to the state maximum of 1.75:1 ratio, while many smaller towns across the state — which do not have much of an industrial base to begin with and therefore would not benefit from a significant shift — maintain a near-equal 1:1 ratio.
Danvers falls into a third category of being a smaller town with a substantial commericial/industrial tax base.
"I can guarantee you that if I were a business owner in this town," Trask said, "and you told me that I only had to pay for the services I consumed, they would embrace doing the police and the fire, and taking the burden of the schools off their shoulders, because they don't send kids to our schools. ...
"It is absolutely political. This is a political discussion about how we are going to further impact businesses in relation to residents."
The Select Board eventually settled on member Michael Bean's originally proposed number — which was more in line with Bernard, but less of a burden shift than she had proposed. Chair Dee Djoko had come in around Bean's range, while Select Board member Daniel Bennett was very close to Trask's proportional increase.
Bennett proposed splitting the difference between the lower number and higher burden shift before eventually joining the majority at the 1.540:1 split.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Danvers Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.