The new ordinance, proposed by City Councilor At-Large Janet Leombruno, and supported by the Mayor and a group of City Councilors, including George King and Mike Cannon, is aimed at substantially changing the membership of the Council On Aging.
Established under Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 40, Section 8B, in 1967, the Council on Aging is Framingham's institutional voice for older residents, charged with identifying their needs, advocating for their interests, and helping ensure that municipal policies, priorities, and senior services respond effectively to those needs.
The Council On Aging has a long standing 11 member at-large model, where members can be drawn from anywhere in the city, with appointments made by the Mayor, subject to City Council approval.
The proposed ordinance aims to change member appointments for the Council On Aging (COA) from that 11 member at-large model to a 9 member district model, where one board member would be appointed from each district.
City Councilor Janet Leombruno has advocated for the change, arguing that it makes the COA membership more representative of the senior community in Framingham, and has presented the change as being based on the representation model which works for the City Council.
In the words of City Councilor, Janet Leombruno, at the September 8, 2026, Council On Aging meeting:
"So instead of having 11, you know, council on aging members, you would do a district. They would be appointed by district, so every single district would have one, one through nine, or then you'd do maybe two at large. And this is something that had come up before at the city council, and this had been discussed in the past at some point, only because of questions about having it be representative like the city, where all the city council seats, one comes from each district. There has been, you know, the thought behind district seats for the council was to kinda give that same equal representation throughout the city."
Here is a video clip, from that meeting, where Leombruno makes that case:
Councilor Leombruno Floats District Restrictions For Council On Aging Members
The major problem with this argument is that it violates the bedrock principle of fair representation, which mandates equal numbers of constituents in each district.
For the City Councilors, who represent districts, their constituents are every resident in their district. They serve them all, from the youngest to the oldest. Each district has about the same number of residents, (~8,000) in line with fair representation requirements.
For Council On Aging members, the constituents are seniors, defined by the state as everyone 60 or older.
The major problem is that each district has very different numbers of seniors.
The variation is enormous, so the representation situation is totally different from the City Council, and a district based approach for the COA cannot be implemented, as it violates the principle of fair and equal representation.
To see that more clearly, the data on residents and seniors can be looked at, and the distinction between City Council and Council On Aging representation explained.
The Full Argument for Rejection of District Based Council On Aging Members
Everyone in Framingham surely remembers the reworking of local precincts and districts which was driven by the 2020 US Census. It was a big deal.
That was done to ensure that each of the 9 districts in Framingham conformed to the principle of fair representation which mandates equal numbers of constituents in each district for the City Council (and the School Committee).
The origin of that principle is found in the US Constitution Article 1, Section 2, Clause 3 and the 14th Amendment, Section 2. Subsequent court cases extended the equal population principle to state legislative districts and local governments.
In our city of about 72,000 residents, that meant making sure that each district contained about 8,000 residents, with a permissible deviation of plus or minus 5%, or 400 residents, a flexibility established by court cases.
That way each City Councilor from each District would serve the same number of constituents, in alignment with those well established, long standing local, state and federal standards.
All is well for the City Council.
But all is not well for the Council On Aging, as the constituents are no longer every resident. The constituents are seniors: residents 60 or older, and there are not even close to equal numbers of them in each district.
Here is the data from the 2020 US Census:
[Note: The state defines seniors as those 60 or over: 60+.]
Here the average number of residents in a district is 8,040 and each district has a resident count within 5% above or below than numbers. That means fair and equal representation is guaranteed for the City Council, as every resident is a constituent.
However, while residents are roughly equally distributed, district by district, there are very large variations in the senior population.
The constituent distribution for the Council On Aging members is very different than that for City Councilors, and fair and equal representation is not achieved.
Districts 1, 3, 4 and 6 have up to 50% more seniors compared to Districts 5, 7 and 8 and roughly twice as many seniors compared to District 9.
The average number of seniors in a district is 1,785, with an allowed deviation of 5%, or 89, for fair and equal representation.
Based on that, only District 4 complies with normal, fair and equal representation rules.
8 districts out of 9 fail the fair and equal representation test.
At the extremes, District 1 has a deviation of 34% above the average, and District 9 has a deviation of 41% below the average.
This is why a district based approach does not pass muster, and the ordinance should be ditched.
Yet the Mayor and A Cohort of City Councilors Persist
Despite this obvious problem, arguments keep on being made by the Mayor and his City Councilor cohort of Janet Leombruno, Mike Cannon and George King, that this is an essential step to make representation of seniors 'fairer' and more like the City Council.
It is clear that the Mayor and his City Councilor cohort, want to single out the Council On Aging, and force a really bad practice on its member appointment process, with the help of other City Councilors.
They keep on ignoring the fact that the problem all along for the Council On Aging has not been its representation model. It has been the failure of the Mayor to fill COA member vacancies for more than a year.
The At-Large Board Appointment Process Works Well
Ditching the proposed ordinance, and retaining the current at-large approach has huge advantages, in addition to protecting seniors' rights to fair representation.
The key is to fill vacancies promptly with qualified applicants.
Witness the Zoning Board of Appeals, the Planning Board and even the elected Board of Library Trustees, where an at-large model works very well, and vacancies do not remain unfilled.
In those examples, and broadly for other boards across the city, the primary appointment criterion has been to make sure candidates have the right qualifications to serve on the relevant board. Their street address does not play any noticeable role.
The recent filling of 2 vacancies on the Board of Library Trustees in a joint City Council/Library Board of Trustees meeting on November 17, 2026, showed how well that works.
There, no one was concerned that up until recently the 12 member board had 4 members resident in District 3. Nor that after filling the vacancies, Districts 1 and 5 have no members and District 4 has 3.
Anyone attending that meeting and reading the candidates' resumes, could see how qualifications counted first, for both the City Councilors and the Library Board Trustees.
Nowhere in that joint meeting did Janet Leombruno, George King or Mike Cannon, or any City Councilor, or the Mayor, argue that the Library Board of Trustees should make sure that every district had a board member.
Everyone worked together to ensure that the outcome for all constituents across the city would be the best, based on appointing the best candidates.
That is exactly what we want for seniors in the city, and we hope that the City Council will recognize that senior needs in the city come ahead of the political maneuvering by the Mayor and some City Councilors, which spawned this proposed ordinance, which tramples on fair representation, and is a device for the Mayor to throw out the current COA members.
The proposed ordinance should be ditched, and pressure put on the Mayor to fill the 5 Council On Aging vacancies promptly, so it can engage in making sure that all the recommendations from the recent senior needs assessment are implemented in the next budget cycle.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Framingham Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.