Business & Tech
Gourmet Pub Grub at James’s Gate
The vegetarian options are many and delicious but the meatless Shepherd's Pie is a true stand-out.
Like its crosstown counterpart, there’s not a single cabbage dish on the menu at but vegetarians will have no trouble finding something tasty to eat at the Irish pub and eatery. has both a bar and an adjacent restaurant. Each side has separate menus but diners are able to order from either menu on both sides.
The lighter and more reasonably priced pub menu has a good selection of veggie appetizers, salads, soup, sandwiches, and entrees. For starters, there are “Nachos” ($10). I didn’t order them but the diners seated nearby certainly seemed to enjoy them. Consisting of tomatoes, black beans, jalapenos, jack cheese, salsa, and sour cream, “Nachos,” washed down with a Guinness or one wide selection of brews, is my admittedly plebian palate's idea of the perfect fusion cuisine. Another delicious veggie appetizer is “Flat Bread Pizza” (minus the linguica,) a round of pita bread topped with spinach, onions, peppers, onions, and cheese.
In the salad department, the pub at offers a “House Salad” ($7 small, $9 large,) “Tomato Bread Salad” ($10), “Blue Cheese, Pear, and Walnut Salad ($10), and“Roasted Beet Salad ($13). The menu describes the “Roasted Beet Salad” as consisting of “red, yellow Chioggia beets, olive oil, shallots, and capers over a petite arugula salad in lemon vinaigrette.” I joked with Galway-born bartender Rory, who I had met previously on a St. Patrick's Day "" visit. (In-between serving customers, the scruffy staffer watched a soccer game on one of the bar's multiple TV screens.) “Isn’t that a little effete for pub grub?” I joked, “Especially the part about the petite arugula salad.” Rory good-humoredly shrugged the comment off, and I presumed that he's just responsible for the drinks and not the sometimes flowery menu descriptions.
Find out what's happening in Jamaica Plainfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
On the day that I visited, the “Vegetarian Soup of the Day” ($4 cup, $6 crock) was a cream of butternut squash. Veggie sandwiches include a “Garden Burger” ($10) with fries, and a “Gouda , Brie, and Pear Sandwich” ($9) with mesclun salad and raspberry vinaigrette.
“Veggie Quesadilla” ($11) is one of the pub’s meatless entrees. The whole wheat tortilla is dressed with spinach, mushrooms, carmelized onions, roasted red peppers, and cheese. Delicious as it sounded, I bypassed the “Veggie Quesadilla” in favor of the “Baked Mac & Cheese” ($11,) which my editor told me he had heard “was one of the best” to be had. The bubbling hot and oven-crisped portion was indeed a delicious interpretation of this all-American classic. Served in a creamy and cheesy but not too rich sauce, the penne was bubbling hot and beautifully oven-crisped on top. Accompanied by a petite mixed green salad, “Mac & Cheese” is a satisfying lunch, and one of the bar menu’s best buys.
Find out what's happening in Jamaica Plainfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Vegetarian options are not as extensive on the more expensive restaurant menu. There are three salads: “House Salad,” “Warm Goat Cheese Salad” ($11), and “Roast Beet Carpaccio” ($13).) The only vegetarian entrees available are the “Pasta” or “Ravioli of the Day” (Both $22). On one visit the “Pasta of the Day” was “Linguine with Mussels” and on a subsequent stop the restaurant offered “Fettucine with Mussels.” The server kindly offered to make both without the seafood but to me that’s a little, as many vegetarians can probably identify with, like ordering a burger without the meat. Instead, I opted for the “Ravioli, which were stuffed with spinach and cheese. The “Ravioli” came in a flavorful white sauce containing a few diced red peppers, and were topped with a portion of fresh greens dressed in vinaigrette. While quite good, $22 did seem a somewhat steep price for six ravioli.
If you don't order off the pub menu, a better idea is to order two of the restaurant’s veggie appetizers. Prepared with parmesan cheese and garlic, and served with lemon wedges and an aioli dipping sauce, the “Artichoke Fritters” (($10), were an absolutely delicious starter. Appearing on the restaurant’s appetizer menu, the “Vegetarian Shepherd’s Pie” ($10) is more than satisfying as an entrée. Although everything that I sampled at was first-rate, the “Vegetarian Shepherd’s Pie” was undoubtedly my favorite dish. Even people who are not fans of eggplant would probably enjoy the original and mouth-watering dish. The base of eggplant, garlic, and tomatoes was long baked almost beyond recognition, and had the color and smooth texture of refried beans. Topped with a perfectly browned crust of mashed potatoes and cheese,“Vegetarian Shepherd’s Pie” deserves to be as equally acclaimed as the restaurant's recommended “Mac & Cheese.”
Service at both the pub and restaurant is friendly and efficient. The décor at is worth noting. The bar has a welcoming atmosphere and features a large fireplace. Though more formal, the elegant restaurant is not stuffy, and often hosts rotating displays of art. With its large outdoor patio, is one of only a few spots in JP’s for al fresco dining. As a writer, the eatery's purposely misplaced apostrophe bothers both me and my spellcheck but considering everything that James' Gate does right, a small grammatical error doesn't matter much. I can't wait to return to try the "Irish Nachos."
(617-983-2000) is located at 5 McBride Street. Pub hours are Tuesday - Saturday 11:30 a.m. – 1 a.m.; Sunday, 12 p.m. – 1 a.m.; Monday, 4 p.m. -1 a.m. Restaurant hours are Tuesday - Sunday, 5:30 p.m. – 10 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, 5:30 p.m. – 11 p.m.
