Saint Paul
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Crime & Safety

Judge Frees MN Man Who Was Pistol-Whipped By Muggers, Then Detained By ICE

A federal judge flagged two very different signatures under one ICE officer's name, among other problems with the arrest.

| Updated

WILLMAR, MN — A federal judge has ordered immigration authorities to release a 48-year-old Willmar man who was taken into ICE custody as he walked out of a county jail, days after he went to a sheriff's office for help following an assault that left him with a fractured skull.

U.S. District Judge Jeffrey M. Bryan granted the man's habeas corpus petition Thursday, finding his detention unlawful for several independent reasons, and ordered that he be released without conditions no later than 4 p.m. Friday.

Subscribe

The man is identified in court records only as Yener G., in line with the District of Minnesota's policy of using only the first name and last initial of nongovernmental parties in immigration cases. A citizen of Guatemala, he has lived and worked in Willmar for about three years, according to the order. He works as a laborer, has two children who live in Willmar with their mother, attends his immigration hearings and has a pending asylum application, the order states.

He first entered the U.S. near Sasabe, Arizona, in August 2023. A Border Patrol agent detained him but let him go after confirming his identity and that he had no criminal record, and he was issued a notice to appear in immigration court. Aside from two misdemeanor driving or traffic citations, his record is clean, the judge wrote.

On or around Sept. 25, the man was mugged and struck in the head and face with a pistol, according to the order. His attackers took his phone, passport and other identification, and he suffered fractures to his skull and cheekbones.

He then went to the Otter Tail County Sheriff's Office seeking help. While there, he was held on an outstanding bench warrant issued after he missed an arraignment on a January 2026 driving citation. He paid $400 bail and was released around Sept. 27, but an ICE agent took him into custody as he was leaving the jail, the order says.

According to ICE records cited in the order, a deportation officer interviewed him by phone in Spanish while he was in the Otter Tail County Jail.

His attorney, Eugene Hummel of the law firm Norton Rose Fulbright, filed the petition Nov. 13. Kandiyohi County Sheriff Eric Tollefson was named as a respondent along with federal immigration officials.

Bryan found the administrative arrest warrant ICE relied on was invalid. The warrant cited statements the man voluntarily made to an immigration officer, but the government offered no evidence of what he said, how long the interview lasted, whether the officer could communicate effectively in Spanish or what the man's mental condition was at the time, the judge wrote. Bryan noted that the man had fractured his skull and cheekbones earlier that day.

The judge also said he could not determine who actually served the warrant. The same officer name and number appeared beside two "markedly different" signatures on two ICE documents, one curved and looping and the other angular.

"These obvious differences cast doubt on who the serving officer was," Bryan wrote.

Bryan further found no evidence that officers identified themselves to the man or told him he was under arrest and why, as federal regulations require. The government also made no argument that he was likely to flee before a warrant could be obtained, which is required for an arrest without a valid warrant, the judge wrote. He pointed out that the man had just been assaulted, had posted bail and had cooperated with agents.

Government attorneys argued the man was subject to mandatory detention under federal immigration law as interpreted by the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Bryan rejected that argument, writing that ICE's own warrant showed he was detained under a different, discretionary provision, and that the government could not change the basis for his detention after the fact.

Bryan also noted that ICE's supporting declaration came from a deportation officer who did not claim personal knowledge of the arrest, and that no officer involved in taking the man into custody submitted a sworn statement.

The order requires government attorneys to file a letter by 11 a.m. Monday confirming the man's release, along with a sworn declaration stating when and where he was released and confirming that his property was returned to him.

The man may also seek attorney's fees and costs, according to the order.

More from Saint Paul
News | 1d
News | 2d
News | 2d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Saint Paul Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information