The Deputy ***1/2 (out of 5) This darkly comic crime film opens with a disheveled slacker named Toby (Duke Nicholson – Jack’s grandson) living in a trailer park being, and getting dumped by his wife for lack of ambition and overall dullness. We soon learn that he’s a part-time deputy sheriff in a dusty little nowhere town near our border with Mexico. He seems to rank somewhere between Barney Fife and Rodney Dangerfield in terms of how much respect he’s accorded by EVERYONE. The sheriff (William H. Macy) likes him but can’t see how Toby could ever earn the promotion to full-time status he craves.
The bullet-riddled body of a local tough guy is found. The sheriff and his crew meander around the corpse while waiting for the forensics experts from some nearby city to take over. Toby is stuck babysitting (bodysitting?) the stiff until the pros arrive. A long day turns into a long night without relief. Toby finally takes a break for a quick boink with a willing nearby lass, but returns to discover that the apparently not-so- dearly departed has departed!
The rest of the proceedings turn chaotic with coyotes (the two-legged smuggling kind, not the quadrupeds who chase Roadrunners) and their truckload of border crossers; the victim’s brothers who wrongly believe Toby is the dude what kilt their kin and are out for revenge; plus an assortment of other residents with a laundry list of grievances. Toby’s numerous calls for help from the rest of the department remain unanswered as he’s bounced from one clash to another by various baddies.
Find out what's happening in Clayton-Richmond Heightsfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
His prolonged isolation while forced to cope with so much beyond his identifiable abilities (or job description) is baffling. The beatings he takes and the things he does while scrambling to stay alive are as surprising to him as they are to the audience. The longer it continues, the funnier it gets… in a morbid way. There’s no laugh-out-loud comedy; just the absurdity of the situation. Anyone up for a murder tale that’s grimly farcical despite no one making jokes is in for a treat.
What makes it work are two factors: Toby reacts competently, more or less, to the string of threats without ever changing his deadpan expression or mostly blase mood. We’re never sure of what his upside potential may be. He might be smarter and tougher than anyone expected, or just the right combination of dumb and lucky to keep on going, as if unfazed by the ordeal. The other factor is plot twists from writers Carlo Bernard and Victor Gischler that work nicely, as the film starts slowly but keeps building as events escalate. This is one of those low-budget sleepers that can easily be overlooked in the crush of high-profile releases. If your sense of humor puts you in the right demographic for this description, check it out.
Find out what's happening in Clayton-Richmond Heightsfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
(The Deputy debuts on Blu-ray and DVD on 11/17/26)