The top 13 face off!

I'm still warming up to the new set, it's starting to grow on me. In my opinion, the highlights Skylar, Jessica and Phillip! Jessica has a great voice, but she seems a bit manufactured. I really didn't feel too much emotion in her performance. I'm amazed at how relaxed they all appear, so kudos to everyone for that. I'm not digging the judging, even though they were a bit more critical, they were still a little too nice and inconsistent in their critiques.

My picks for the bottom include: Elise, Jeremy and Shannon, but everyone has garnered a fan base during these past few months so it won't be all about the best performance and vocals, we'll have to factor in their fan base too.

Good luck to everyone! I'm rooting for you all, but in the end, there can be only one American Idol!

What do you think? Did the judges make the right call?