Politics & Government

Scanlan Makes His Pitch: Keep Politics Out, Keep Me In As NH SOS

All three Democrats have suggested changes to how NH votes, including expanded mail-in ballots and online voter registration.

Secretary of State David Scanlan announces his re-election bid, Nov. 17, 2026.
Secretary of State David Scanlan announces his re-election bid, Nov. 17, 2026. (Leonard Robinson/NH Journal)

Secretary of State David Scanlan announced Tuesday that, despite the legislature’s overwhelming Democratic majority, he’s running to keep his job in the next session.

New Hampshire is one of just three states where the secretary of state is selected by the legislature. Thirty-five states elect theirs via popular vote. Scanlan, a Republican, is widely expected to be ousted by the Democratic supermajority elected in November’s blue wave.

Find out what's happening in Across New Hampshirefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Three Democrats have already announced their candidacies:

  • Carleigh Beriont, a former candidate for Congress in the 1st District who chairs the Hampton Board of Selectmen;
  • James Butler, who worked on New Hampshire voter data and targeting for America Votes, a national progressive political organization;
  • And Manchester state Rep. Patrick Long.

And while the Democrats are campaigning on a pledge to promote voter participation and protect the state’s first-in-the-nation primary, Scanlan argues that he’s already doing both.

Find out what's happening in Across New Hampshirefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

“My approach is well known. I know what’s involved with setting the date for the presidential primary, and I know the messaging that needs to be stated to protect it,” Scanlan said. “What is their approach? They’re going to say protect and defend it, but there are very few details to go along with that statement.”

All three Democrats have suggested changes to how New Hampshire votes, embracing ideas ranging from no-excuse absentee voting to expanded mail-in ballots and online voter registration.

Scanlan argued that his Democratic challengers are unaware of the complexities surrounding some of their proposals, many of which have been championed by left-wing groups.

“They have come up with these proposals that are pushed by organizations like 603 Forward and others, but what they don’t understand is that New Hampshire is uniquely different from the other states around the country and the proposals they are pushing are a one-size-fits-all approach,” Scanlan said. “New Hampshire, for instance, has a constitutional provision that says a voter can vote by absentee if they are absent or if they have a disability. To do those other things would require a change to the state constitution.”

603 Forward, which has endorsed Butler, went to court to prevent the state from requiring people who register to vote without a photo ID on Election Day to use an affidavit ballot rather than having their ballots immediately included with the rest cast that day.

As for the presidential primary, the fact that national Democrats have now twice stripped the state of its FITN status raises questions about how hard a Democratic secretary of state would fight his or her own party. Beriont and Butler claim it’s a top issue in their campaigns, while Long has not publicly stated his position.

The previous secretary of state, Bill Gardner, was a Democratic state representative who had widespread support among Republicans while overseeing the state’s election system. Republican Scanlan served as his deputy and is also popular with the GOP.

“I have worked with a number of secretaries of state over the last 40+ years. The office has been and should remain a nonpartisan safeguard of fair elections and political impartiality,” Republican strategist and former Attorney General Tom Rath posted on Tuesday. “Secretary of State Scanlan has upheld the integrity of NH elections. He should continue to do so.”

Asked about endorsements, Scanlan said he won’t seek them, either from Gardner or from any individuals or organizations.

“I’m seeking this office on the basis of my own record, and it’s a strong one,” he said. “I’m not seeking endorsements. I think it’s wrong to have endorsements from organizations that have been pushing an election agenda because that would just fuel the partisanship argument moving forward.”

Scanlan was eager to tout the high turnout of the Nov. 3 elections in New Hampshire as evidence that voters remained confident in his leadership. Estimates placed New Hampshire among the top five states in the country for voter turnout.

“New Hampshire is in the top tier of voter turnout of all states around the country,” Scanlan told reporters on Tuesday. “It is easy for voters to participate in the process and we see that time after time.”

Democrats are trying to paint Scanlan as a hard-core GOP partisan, pointing to his application of HB 323, which removed student IDs from the list of acceptable forms of identification necessary to obtain a ballot. Scanlan issued a directive to election officials instructing poll workers not to accept student IDs when registering new voters.

Open Democracy, a left-wing activist group, filed a lawsuit ahead of the Sept. 8 primary against the state of New Hampshire, asking the U.S. District Court for the District of New Hampshire to overturn the law on constitutional grounds.

On Oct. 2, U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante ruled that HB 323 could remain in effect, but that Scanlan must update the guidance to allow for student IDs to be used to establish identity.

After appeals to the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and ultimately the Supreme Court, Scanlan’s directive remained in place and was used on Nov. 3.

Scanlan took a victory lap on the issue, speaking to reporters on Tuesday.

“If you look at the voter turnout and look for complaints about students being unable to register to vote, there are very few, if any, of those,” Scanlan said. “It’s not an issue in reality. It’s a political issue, and if the legislature wants to change the law to something different, then I will follow it.”

And Scanlan reminded reporters of his ongoing feud with the U.S. Department of Justice, proof that he could go toe-to-toe with a Republican White House.

In 2025, the U.S. Department of Justice demanded access to New Hampshire’s voter registration database from Scanlan and threatened criminal prosecution if he failed to comply.

“There was a letter that was sent to me that said if I did not ensure certain steps or take certain actions that criminal prosecution is not out of the question,” Scanlan said. “I am very comfortable with the position that I have taken despite threats from the federal government. I have followed the law, both federal and state, and I’m very confident that I have run the best elections in New Hampshire.”

With a 292-108 Democratic-to-Republican majority, Scanlan’s path to keeping his office includes gaining the support of many newly elected Democrats. Scanlan said that he will participate in Democratic Party-organized forums on Thursday and Sunday.

He said that he expects his key pitch to resonate with both Democrats and Republicans ahead of Organization Day: “I have followed the Constitution and the law during my tenure, whether it’s a Democratic law or a Republican law. The law is the law.”


This story was originally published by the NH Journal, an online news publication dedicated to providing fair, unbiased reporting on, and analysis of, political news of interest to New Hampshire. For more stories from the NH Journal, visit NHJournal.com.

More from Across New Hampshire