Politics & Government
Terling: What NH GOP Can Learn About Comebacks From British Right
Think tank chief of staff: Within the GOP, the blame game about the blue tsunami began immediately. But even moderate Republicans lost.

Coming from England, I encountered no shortage of culture shocks during the three weeks I spent in New Hampshire for this year’s midterm elections.
A prayer, the Pledge of Allegiance, and the national anthem before dinner — something we in Europe are far too secular and unpatriotic even to fathom — was a first. Hearing someone with a distinctly American accent describe themselves as “Welsh” was a highlight. I also visited my first gun store and was offered a few souvenirs to take home, none of which, sadly, would likely have made it through customs at Heathrow Airport.
Find out what's happening in Across New Hampshirefor free with the latest updates from Patch.
I did, however, bring some takeaways back to the U.K.
New Hampshire is a remarkable place, and I don’t just mean its fall foliage. The state really does live up to its motto, “Live Free or Die,” showing what can be achieved when you resist the slow encroachment of government.
Find out what's happening in Across New Hampshirefor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The results of that speak for themselves: New Hampshire tops national rankings for economic freedom, opportunity, public safety and child well-being, and the list goes on. As a Brit, I was astounded that your state levies no personal income tax, including on capital gains, dividends and interest, and no inheritance tax. It does all this while retaining its position as the best state for fiscal burden.
This is the result of a political establishment with deep-rooted conservative and libertarian traditions, one that the midterm elections saw undergo a profound change. Democrats took control of New Hampshire’s state Senate, House of Representatives, and Executive Council.
I spent much of my time in the Granite State observing the campaign of former Sen. John Sununu as he fought an uphill battle to return to the U.S. Senate.
As we all know, that battle was unfortunately unsuccessful. Granite State voters made their choice for Chris Pappas clear. Now that the dust has settled on the midterms, however, it is worth reflecting on what that decision means for New Hampshire and the country.
Sununu was, of course, far from the only Republican to lose. Cindy Hyde-Smith has just joined a long list of Republicans defeated by Democrats this November.
Within the GOP, the blame game began almost immediately. Potential presidential hopeful Ron DeSantis described the results as close to an “extinction-level event” for Republicans in many parts of the country. Analysts searching for the cause of the Democratic tsunami were also quick to point to President Donald Trump and his administration. Whatever your opinion of the president, even his most loyal supporters would be hard-pressed to deny a connection between some of his decisions over the past two years and the midterm results.
However, those who oppose him and may have welcomed the results should also recognize that many good, moderate Republicans were denied the opportunity to serve in Congress. Neither John Sununu nor Susan Collins can be described as overtly “MAGA” — their careers in the GOP began long before there was such a thing — and their defeats are a loss to the whole party. Any political organization is healthier for having a broad spectrum of opinion within it.
Watching election night unfold reminded me of Britain’s 2024 general election, when our Conservative Party suffered its worst defeat in its 192-year electoral history. That felt like a true extinction-level event. Unlike the GOP, the Tories also faced an upstart challenger, Reform UK, threatening to displace them as the dominant force on the British right.
Two years later, however, Reform has yet to achieve that ambition. The Conservatives have regained second place in polling averages, and the Conservative leader, Kemi Badenoch, ranks as Britain’s most popular party leader. Their recovery remains incomplete, but the party has gone from an afterthought to a serious electoral contender once again.
That recovery required serious inward reflection and an overhaul of the party’s policies and message. After 14 years of Conservative government, during which failures were hardly uncommon, the Tories needed new faces at the top, new ideas, and a renewed case to put to the British people.
Perhaps, then, the Conservative story is one for the GOP to study. In little more than two years, a party many had written off has rebuilt its understanding with the electorate. If Republicans can do the same, why should a Republican victory in the 2028 presidential election be out of reach? Democrats may feel unstoppable, but having no enemy in your sights can also make it easier to let your guard down. Anything is possible in politics. After all, Trump won in 2016.
On John Sununu, although the electorate chose otherwise, I remain convinced that he would have made a fine senator for New Hampshire. In a different political climate, he might well have returned to the seat he held nearly two decades ago.
I feel, therefore, that it is a great shame that John Sununu will not have that chance to add to his family’s combined 26 years of service at the helm of Granite State politics. One can therefore only hope that Chris Pappas serves the state well in their absence.
Viggo Terling is Chief of Staff at the Adam Smith Institute, a British think tank, and served as an observer on the Sununu for Senate campaign during the 2026 midterm elections. He wrote this for NHJournal.com.
This story was originally published by the NH Journal, an online news publication dedicated to providing fair, unbiased reporting on, and analysis of, political news of interest to New Hampshire. For more stories from the NH Journal, visit NHJournal.com.