State Responses to Substance Abuse Among Pregnant Women

The Guttmacher Report on Public Policy

December 2000, Volume 3, Number 6

State Responses to Substance Abuse Among Pregnant Women

By Cynthia Dailard and Elizabeth Nash

With the U.S. Supreme Court considering a high-profile case involving the prosecution of pregnant substance abusers, policymakers and advocates once again are confronted with the decade-old question of how best to deal with pregnant women who use drugs. State laws now vary considerably in their approach to the problem, reflecting a deep division in public opinion. For many lawmakers, the issue comes down to the difficult task of balancing a woman's right to bodily integrity with society's interest in ensuring healthy pregnancies, and the question of whether punitive approaches will foster—or hinder—healthy outcomes for women and children.

Child Welfare Laws

Meanwhile, several states have expanded their child welfare laws to address prenatal drug exposure (treating the issue as a matter of civil rather than criminal law). These laws vary considerably in their scope and approach. Laws in 12 states (see table,) specify either that a child born exposed to drugs is presumed to be abused or neglected or that positive results from a toxicology test performed on a newborn or signs of prenatal drug exposure in newborns constitute evidence of child abuse or neglect. In these states, such evidence provides grounds for removing the infant from the mother's custody and qualifies as a factor in determining whether to terminate parental rights.

(Notice how New Hampshire is NOT one of the twelve States, yet in fact DO remove newborn's from Mother's for alleged prenatal substance use and DO charge them with Neglect.)

Under the South Carolina law, for example, a newborn is presumed to be neglected and "cannot be protected from further harm without being removed from the custody of the mother" if there is a positive drug test on either the mother or the child at birth.

Additionally, the Ohio Supreme Court, in its October decision In re Baby Boy Blackshear, found that a newborn testing positive for drug exposure is per se an abused child under the state's civil child abuse law, even though the law makes no mention of prenatal drug exposure. The law defines an "abused child" as one who suffers "physical or mental injury that harms or threatens to harm the child's health or welfare." Unlike the lower court, the supreme court said that it need not address whether a fetus is a child under the state's child abuse law, since a "postbirth" drug test indicated that drug exposure, and therefore abuse, had occurred. Accordingly, the state was justified, the court said, in its decision to terminate parental rights. State supreme courts in Connecticut and New York, however, have refused to treat pregnant women who used drugs as presumptively neglectful, while the New Jersey Supreme Court held that a newborn's addiction and symptoms of withdrawal, combined with a mother's failure to provide care, could be considered as a factor in terminating parental rights.

Other states require health care professionals to report or test for prenatal drug exposure—information that the state may use as evidence in child welfare proceedings. Health care professionals in seven states are required to report to the state if a newborn tests positive for drug exposure or if a pregnant woman shows evidence of drug use. In Iowa, Minnesota and Virginia, health care professionals are required to test some or all pregnant women or newborns for prenatal drug exposure. Kentucky law says that provided a woman is given notice, a physician may screen her for drug use and then determine whether to make a report to the state. In Iowa and Kentucky, however, test results may not be used as prosecutorial evidence.

Read More:

Laws Pertaining to Pregnant Women Who Use Drugs

State     Civil Child Welfare*       Reporting Requirements             Testing Requirements   Civil Commitment           Drug Treatment†

Alabama                                                                              

Alaska                                                                   

Arizona                               X                                            X

Arkansas                                                                             X

California                                                                           X

Colorado                                                                            X

Connecticut                                                                      X

Delaware                                                                            

Florida  X                                                            X

Georgia                                                                               X

Hawaii                                                                  

Idaho                                                                    

Illinois  X             X                                            X

Indiana X                                                             

Iowa                     X             X                             

Kansas                                                                 X

Kentucky                                                                            X

Louisiana                                                                            X

Maine                                                                   

Maryland             X                                                            X

Massachusetts                 X                                             

Michigan                            X                                             

Minnesota          X             X             X             X             X

Mississippi                                                                         

Missouri                                                                             X

Montana                                                                              

Nebraska                                                                            X

Nevada                X                                                             

New Hampshire                                                                               

New Jersey                                                                        

New Mexico                                                                      

New York                                                                           X

North Carolina                                                                 X

North Dakota                                                                     

Ohio                                                                     X

Oklahoma                                                                          X

Oregon                                                                X

Pennsylvania                                                                    X

Rhode Island     X                                                             

South Carolina  X                                                             

South Dakota     X                                            X            

Tennessee                                                                          

Texas    X                                                            X

Utah                     X                                             

Vermont                                                                              

Virginia                X                            X                            X

Washington                                                                      X

West Virginia                                                                    

Wisconsin           X                                            X             X