Who Has The Best Pizza In Cinnaminson?

Cinnaminson, NJ -- Everyone loves a good slice of pizza, and there’s fewer places in America that make better pizza than New Jersey. How’s the pizza in Cinnaminson?

Yelp! gives voice to anyone who’s ever eaten pizza in Cinnaminson. So what do Yelp! users think about the pizza they can get in town? Below is a sample of Cinnaminson pizza reviews posted on Yelp!

Goody’s Pizza (4 ½ star average; 1204 Route 130 North; 856-303-4177). Some sample reviews:

“So happy to have found my new pizzeria. The crust is thin and flavorful, the amount of spicing is perfect, and they aren't skimpy with the cheese (and just the right amount of oil- mmmmmm). This is a legit NJ pizzeria. Can't wait to try their Brooklyn. We will definitely become regulars.”

“Wife and I have been looking for a new pizza place since our old go to must have changed cooks and the taste went out with the old cook. After several local places we got a mailer from Goody's on Rt. 130 in Cinnaminson and decided to check it out for a quick lunch bite. We chose a slice of pepperoni & a slice of their Brooklyn pie. A thin crust square pie with fresh mozzarella and sauce which is made in house, with some basil on top. Taste was excellent on both the Brooklyn & the pepperoni which also has a thinner crust which we prefer. They offer a few tables to eat in although they are known for delivery to a wide area. Staff was very pleasant and helpful. Plenty of parking. Will definitely be coming back in the future.”

“Got a menu in the mail and decided to check it out for lunch. Plenty of parking, and when you go in they offer a cozy little eating area. The husband and I both ordered a slice of the Brooklyn and a slice of pepperoni. The young lady served our slices and offered to get us any spices if we wanted. We both tasted the Brooklyn first and the freshness of the cheese was the first thing we noticed. The sauce had a delicate sweetness and topped with thin slices basil allowed the flavors to meld nicely. The pepperoni was what we expected and we both enjoyed the thin crust. Spoke with the owner and learned they make their own fresh mozzarella and sauce on the premises. We will so be going back.”

Nick’s Pizza & Pasta (4 star average; 141 Route 130 South; 856-829-0400). Some sample reviews:

“Back east visiting family & had to stop in Nick's again. It was even better than I remembered. By ‘Philly’ standards you can not get a good cheesesteak in Ohio. Nick's cheesesteak is piled high with perfectly cooked and flavorful meat, with great cheese melting throughout and served in the perfect roll. The fries are hot and crisp - not greasy. The pizza is also really good...thin crust with perfect balance of sauce and cheese. Mouth is watering as I write this....what more can I say??”

“Great pizza for a great price. I have had a few different types of slices from this restaurant and every single time it has been good. Fresher is always better so if you can get a fresh pue but I will guarantee you will enjoy it either way.”

“Only pizza worth driving miles for. Been a customer since they opened in '78 as Brothers in the back of Clover Square. No matter how far away I move I'll always drive "home" for this pizza. Nick and family are great people and after all this time and not knowing them personally the always greet you like old friends. 15 minutes away now and it's the only pizza we'll order. Their cheesesteaks are also the best around. The woman who cooks the steaks has been doing a great job for a very very long time.”

Italian Brick Oven Pizzeria (3 ½ star average; 1901 Cinnaminson Avenue; 856-786-4800). Some sample reviews:

“This little gem has the Best wings I have ever had in jersey! And I had a lot of wings, the jug, pick a Lilly, whistlers etc.. The wing sauce is amazing! And the pizza is real! I won't order pizza from anywhere else in this area! The delivery drivers are Fast! 20-30 mins never longer.”

“I have had their pizza many times plain cheese and with assorted toppings, definitely one of the better pizza places around. Their cheese steak pizza is excellent and they have awesome wings.”

“Best pizza in Cinnaminson, hands down. Perfect blend of spices...sauce is yummy. White with broccoli and ricotta possibly one of the best I ever had. Only negative I'd say is it is kind of pricey! Appreciate more specials! But I would probably still pay for the pizza, lol.”

Do you agree? Where do you like to go to get your pizza? Tell us in the comments.

Patch file photo

Get Patch breaking news alerts sent right to your phone with our new app. Download here.