Sports
Dissecting What Went Wrong In Monmouth University's Upset Loss To Merrimack
Following stunning loss to Merrimack, Hawks clinch CAA championship with Campbell loss

WEST LONG BRANCH - Senior Day at Kessler Stadium was supposed to be a celebration, and for most of the afternoon it was, until it unraveled in the final two minutes. Monmouth led 21-12 at halftime and held that edge for most of the day, but A.J. Hairston's four touchdown passes kept Merrimack within reach, and a 61-yard strike to Austin Palmer cut the deficit to 28-26. With 1:50 left, Frankie Weaver was intercepted at the Merrimack 20, and Mike Ryan's 38-yard field goal with 15 seconds remaining sealed a 29-28 stunner that ended the No. 20 Hawks' seven-game winning streak and their perfect home record.
The mood in the locker room was heavy, with the 8-3 Hawks left to stew over a game they felt they should have won. Then, roughly two hours later, everything changed. Elon rallied from a 17-0 halftime hole to upset Campbell, 28-24, and with that result, Monmouth clinched the outright Coastal Athletic Association championship at 7-0 in league play, along with the conference's automatic bid to the FCS playoffs. A day that began with heartbreak ended with the Hawks as CAA champions.
The title and the automatic bid are already secured, but Saturday's finale at Campbell still carries major weight for the Hawks, because playoff seeding remains at stake. The 24-team bracket will be unveiled Nov. 22, with the top 16 teams seeded and the top eight earning first-round byes. Every game before the national championship is played on a campus site, so a seed can mean the difference between hosting a playoff game at Kessler Stadium and packing the bus for a long road trip. A win over the 16th-ranked Camels would give Monmouth nine victories and a stronger résumé heading into the committee's room, while a second straight loss could cost the Hawks ground in the seeding conversation.
Find out what's happening in Long Branch-Eatontownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
For Campbell, the stakes are even higher. The Camels (8-3, 5-2 CAA) were one win from sharing the conference crown before falling to Elon; now they are fighting for their postseason lives. With no automatic bid available, Campbell must hope the selection committee chooses it as one of the at-large teams, and beating the league champion on its home field would be the best argument it could make. That sets up a desperate opponent for a Monmouth team that will have its hands full with the Camels, who are ranked 21st in the country, one spot below Monmouth at No.20 in the latest AFCA FCS Coaches Poll.
“They came out and took it to us,” said Monmouth head coach Jeff Gallo. “They outcoached us, outplayed us, and were more physical. We played sloppy with penalties and turnovers at the end. We didn’t play to our standards; it’s as simple as that. We still had a chance to win, a chance to put the game away, but couldn’t. We still have everything in front of us, so we have to get right back to work.”
Find out what's happening in Long Branch-Eatontownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
BREAKING DOWN WHAT WENT WRONG IN THE LOSS
RUSHING OFFENSE WAS SMOTHERED BY MORE PHYSICAL MERRIMACK FRONT: Monmouth’s rushing offense entered the game ranked 16th in the country, averaging 200 yards per game. Merrimack’s rushing defense, by contrast, entered the game ranked 19th at stopping the run. After holding the Hawks to 89 yards rushing on 36 attempts (2.47 yards per carry), they moved up four spots to No. 15, allowing 111.9 yards per game. Monmouth had no answer for the more physical Warriors, whose defensive line shockingly manhandled the Hawks' highly rated offensive line. Monmouth’s longest run from scrimmage was a 15-yard gallop by Elijah Jennings. The offensive line also struggled to protect quarterback Frankie Weaver, who was under constant pressure all afternoon, but somehow managed to make some outstanding throws with multiple Merrimack defenders in his face. Weaver was sacked three times, but that number could’ve easily tripled. On Weaver’s third touchdown pass of the day, two Warriors were draped all over him and still made a perfect throw. It was like that for Weaver for much of the game.
WEAVER’S EPIC PASSING DAY OVERSHADOWED BY LATE INTERCEPTION: Under duress all afternoon, Weaver was poised, fearless, and remarkably accurate under the circumstances. He delivered one brilliant throw after another, carrying the Hawks’ offense with a gutsy, razor-sharp performance, until a single late interception proved to be a fatal blow. Weaver completed 28-of-47 passes for 361 yards and four touchdowns, but his late interception paved the way for Merrimack’s comeback. After a Warrior touchdown pulled them to within two points, 28-26, the Hawks were driving with the hope of putting the game away. On third-and-14 from the Merrimack 39-yard line with two minutes remaining in the fourth quarter, Weaver’s pass intended for Christian Harrison was overthrown, picked off by Garrett Jackson, and returned to the Warriors' 46-yard line. Merrimack then advanced to the 21-yard line before kicking the winning 39-yard field goal. The loss definitely doesn’t fall on Weaver’s shoulders. The defense, which allowed Merrimack’s offense to rack up 414 yards of total offense, 100-plus yards over its average, could’ve put up a better fight and derailed the Warriors' winning drive.
MERRIMACK QUARTERBACK A.J. HAIRSTON TORCHES MONMOUTH’S DEFENSIVE SECONDARY: Entering the game, Merrimack’s passing offense was ranked 117th in the country. Following Saturday’s game, they jumped all the way up to No. 81 with a 185.5-yard-per-game average. Merrimack redshirt sophomore quarterback Hairston, who came into the game completing just 53.6% of his passes for 1,442 with seven touchdowns and seven interceptions, had a career day against the porous Monmouth defensive backfield. He completed an efficient 17-of-21 passing attempts for a career-best 344 yards and four touchdowns. Their 29 points are a season-high for a team that has struggled to put points on the board all season. The Hawks' pass rush was non-existent until the fourth quarter, giving Hairston all day to pick apart the secondary, which was caught sleeping twice on first down and gave up long touchdown passes in the blink of an eye. Late in the second quarter, Monmouth had just taken a 14-6 lead on a Weaver 23-yard touchdown pass to Jennings. Merrimack took over on their own 25-yard line and on first down, Hairston found a wide-open Auston Palmer, who raced untouched for a 75-yard touchdown. Then, in the middle of the fourth quarter, with the Hawks up 28-19, the Warriors fielded a punt and took over at the 39-yard line. Again, on first down, Hairston found an open receiver, this time for a 61-yard touchdown to pull them to within 28-26. Whether it was mental lapses, schemes, a breakdown in communication, or coaching, the players were out of position, and that needs to be addressed immediately, especially with Campbell quarterback Kamden Sixkiller, a potential All-American candidate this season, on deck next.
MISSED FIELD GOAL COMES BACK TO HAUNT HAWKS: On Monmouth’s first possession of the game, they drove to the Merrimack nine-yard line, but a Weaver third-and-5 pass fell incomplete, setting up a 29-yard chip-shot field goal. However, placekicker Sky Sholder, who had seemed to overcome some early-season misses, shanked one wide left with the wind at his back. The kick was easy to brush off at the time, but in a game the Hawks lost by a single point, those three missed points loomed large.
Redshirt junior wideout Tra Neal caught a game-high 10 passes from Weaver for 139 yards and two touchdowns. For the season, Neal has 59 receptions for 816 yards and seven touchdowns, third in the Coastal Athletic Association. Redshirt senior Gavin Nelson added seven receptions for 97 yards and one touchdown, bringing him to 61 receptions for 683 yards and five touchdowns, good for seventh place in the CAA. Weaver ranks third in the CAA with 2508 passing yards and is tied for second with 21 passing touchdowns.
Next week’s game against Campbell in Buies, North Carolina, is scheduled for 12:00 p.m. Saturday and will be streamed live on Flo College Sports Network.