Fatal Police Shooting In Newark 2 Years Ago Hasn’t Been Forgotten

NEWARK, NJ — Gathering on New Year’s Day – the second anniversary of his death – family members of Carl Dorsey III and Newark activists continued to demand action from state prosecutors in the wake of a fatal police shooting that was captured on video.

On Sunday, the People’s Organization For Progress (POP) held a news conference in front of 153 Halsey Street, calling on the New Jersey attorney general’s office to provide an update on the investigation into the police shooting that claimed Dorsey’s life in 2021.

“The attorney general’s office has had this case for two years,” POP chair Lawrence Hamm said. “We have not had an official statement on the progress of the case during that time.”

“Two years is too long,” Hamm emphasized.

The POP is also calling for the City of Newark to fire the detective that killed Dorsey, a federal investigation into his death by the U.S. Attorney for New Jersey to determine if his civil rights were violated, and the establishment of police review boards in Newark and other municipalities with subpoena and investigatory powers. Read More: NJ Supreme Court Limits Newark's Power To Probe Police Abuse

Newark Communities for Accountable Policing also supported the call for action on the Dorsey case.

Advocates have maintained that Dorsey, 39, was unarmed during the shooting, which took place on New Year’s Day. Read More: Police-Involved Shooting In Newark Raises Questions, Spurs Rally

In the wake of the police shooting, New Jersey Attorney General’s Office released video surveillance footage taken at the scene, as well as the following statement:

“According to the preliminary investigation, the shooting occurred shortly after midnight near Woodland Avenue and South 11th Street in Newark, N.J. Officers responded to the area on reports of gunfire. After Detective [Rod] Simpkins got out of his car, there was brief physical contact between him and Mr. Dorsey and Detective Simpkins fired his 9mm service weapon one time, striking Mr. Dorsey. No firearm was recovered from Mr. Dorsey or his immediate area. Officers provided medical aid to Mr. Dorsey and he was transported by emergency medical personnel to University Hospital in Newark, where he was pronounced deceased at approximately 1:37 a.m. While the Newark Police Department employs body and dash cameras, there is no police video of the incident. The officers in this case, including Detective Simpkins, were in plain clothes and in unmarked vehicles, and were not equipped with body or dash cameras.”

The footage shared by the attorney general’s office – which comes from a nearby security camera – shows a chaotic scene, with several people running in panic after apparently hearing a gunshot. It can be seen here.

The week prior to the shooting, the Newark Public Safety Department said that no local police officer had fired a shot in 2020, which some experts lauded as a major accomplishment and a sign that reforms in the department are working. Read More: Violent Crime Up In Newark For 2021, But Down Over 3-Year Period

After reviewing video footage of the shooting last year, Mayor Ras Baraka said he found it to be “tragic and disturbing,” but also “incomplete.” Baraka added that the city and its police department would be looking into expanding the use of body cameras to include plainclothes units. Read More: Newark Mayor On Police Shooting: 'Tragic, Disturbing, Incomplete'

That new policy took effect in January 2021. Read More: Newark Now Requires Most Plainclothes Cops To Wear Body Cameras

Last summer, Dorsey’s family filed a lawsuit against the officer who shot him, several other unnamed officers, the local police department and the city.

The civil lawsuit is seeking punitive damages, costs and attorney fees. It accuses police of committing excessive force during the encounter, and accuses the city of failing to train officers properly. Read More: NJ Family Files Lawsuit After Fatal Police Shooting In Newark

Send local news tips and correction requests to eric.kiefer@patch.com. Learn more about advertising on Patch here. Find out how to post announcements or events to your local Patch site. Don’t forget to visit the Patch Newark Facebook page.