Bay Shore
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Health & Fitness

Recalled Cheese May Have Reached 28 Long Island Stores: FDA

The Bay Shore distributor's cheese may have reached 19 Suffolk County and 9 Nassau retailers.

The FDA said a recall of 1-pound packages of Requeson cheese distributed by Bay Shore-based Nelson & Isa Lacteos LLC due to possible Listeria contamination. (FDA)

BAY SHORE, NY — Requeson cheese recalled by a Bay Shore distributor may have been sold at 28 stores across Long Island, federal health officials said.

Nelson & Isa Lacteos LLC recalled 1-pound packages of Requeson Cheese because of potential contamination with Listeria monocytogenes. The cheese was distributed to New York retailers from May 15 through May 28 in plastic clamshell containers, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

Subscribe

The product has no listed brand name and was likely repackaged by individual stores, meaning its labeling and coding may differ depending on where it was purchased, officials said.

The recall began after New York State inspectors detected Listeria in an unopened 18-pound container of Clover Hill Dairy Requeson Cheese.

The container had a June 14 sell-by date and batch number 2AA051526. The recalled 1-pound packages were repacked from that contaminated batch, according to the FDA.

The FDA said it has reason to believe the following stores received the recalled cheese:

Suffolk County

Central Islip

  • Victoria Bakery, 1645 Islip Ave., Central Islip
  • Claros Variedades, 126 W. Suffolk Ave., Central Islip
  • Jocorena Bakery No. 1, 1066 Islip Ave., Central Islip
  • Compare Foods, 1070 Islip Ave., Central Islip
  • Brentwood

    Bay Shore

  • Exelencia Bakery, 3 Candlewood Road, Bay Shore
  • Copiague

  • Fine Fare Super Market, 870 Merrick Road, Copiague
  • Mi Plaza Variedades No. 2, 60 Railroad Ave., Copiague
  • Mastic

  • Gaby's Variedades, 1280 Montauk Highway, Mastic
  • East End

    Nassau County

    Farmingdale

    Uniondale

  • Shop Fair Market, 973 Front St., Uniondale
  • Cecia Variedades, 959 Front St., Uniondale
  • Rinconcito Variedades, 606 Jerusalem Ave., Uniondale
  • Hempstead

  • Rinconcito Salvadoreno, 230 Front St., Hempstead
  • Segobias Bakery, 279 Jerusalem Ave., Hempstead
  • Long Beach

    Freeport

    The FDA cautioned that its list might not include every store that received the cheese and could include locations that ultimately did not receive it.

    Broader Outbreak Includes Death

    The company said on June 5 no illnesses or complaints had been reported specifically in connection with the Nelson & Isa recall.

    Federal officials connected Clover Hill Dairy cheese to a broader, multistate and multiyear Listeria outbreak. As of the FDA's June 24 update, 12 people had become sick in New York, Maryland, Virginia and Illinois. Ten were hospitalized and one person died.

    Testing found that multiple cheese samples and environmental samples taken from Clover Hill Dairy matched the outbreak strain, officials said. The Maryland company later expanded its recall to include all cheese manufactured at its facility.

    Listeria can cause fever, severe headaches, stiffness, nausea, abdominal pain and diarrhea. Infections can be serious or fatal for young children, older adults and people with weakened immune systems. The bacteria can also cause miscarriages and stillbirths among pregnant women.

    Consumers should not eat the recalled product and should return it to the place of purchase for a refund. Questions can be directed to Nelson & Isa Lacteos at 631-334-1055 between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m.

    More from Bay Shore
    News | Jul 10
    News | Jul 5
    News | Jul 3
    See more on Patch >

    Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
    Bay Shore Patch

    Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
    Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

    ©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

    Do Not Sell My Personal Information