HUNTINGTON, NY — A proposed 18.39 percent property tax levy increase in Huntington was derailed Tuesday night after council members introduced dozens of last-minute budget amendments aimed at keeping the town within New York's property tax cap.
The Nov. 17 Town Board meeting turned into an hours-long debate over spending reductions, revenue projections and the use of reserves, with residents expressing both relief at the prospect of avoiding the proposed increase and frustration with how the changes were presented.
Councilwoman Theresa Mari introduced 39 amendments to Supervisor Ed Smyth's proposed 2027 operating budget, while Councilwoman Jen Hebert introduced an additional measure eliminating $300,000 in spending on leaf bags for residents.
The amendments generally passed 3-0, with Mari, Hebert and Councilman Dave Bennardo voting in favor and Smyth and Councilwoman Brooke Lupinacci abstaining.
The final vote to adopt the amended budget failed 2-3, with Bennardo and Mari voting yes and Smyth, Hebert and Lupinacci voting no.
Under New York Town Law Section 109, if the board does not adopt a budget by Nov. 20, the preliminary budget, incorporating changes already approved by the board, becomes the budget for the following fiscal year.
The amended preliminary budget is positioned to take effect Friday unless the board adopts another budget before the deadline. The failed final vote does not automatically reinstate Smyth's original proposal, which called for an 18.39 percent increase in Huntington's property tax levy, exceeding the town's calculated 2.68 percent allowable increase under New York's property tax cap by approximately $22.55 million, according to figures presented during the meeting.
"When the proposed 2027 budget was presented and proposed piercing the cap by 18.39 percent, I decided that I needed to try to find some solutions," Mari said.
Among the largest changes was a proposal to defer hiring for 21 vacant general fund positions until October 2027, generating an estimated $2 million in savings from salaries, payroll taxes and health insurance.
Mari said no existing employees would be laid off, and the positions could be filled earlier if necessary and replacement funding was identified.
Other amendments included reducing budgeted health insurance expenses by approximately $1.12 million, eliminating $1.5 million in new open space preservation funding and drawing approximately $2 million from the refuse district's fund balance. The board also approved a proposal to recognize approximately $2.72 million in outstanding code violation penalties as revenue, although questions remain about whether the entire amount can be collected.
The board also approved an amendment recognizing $3.5 million in federal funding designated for highway paving, prompting an objection from Highway Superintendent Andre Sorrentino, who questioned how the money would be allocated.
"So we're going to take 3.5 million that was given to us to pave Huntington roads, and you're going to take it," Sorrentino said. "Is it going in the highway budget? Because it's made for paving."
The board said the funding had to remain within the Highway Department, and an aide to U.S. Rep. Nick LaLota also confirmed the money could only be used for paving.
While the amendments received majority support, board members expressed concerns about having insufficient time to review them.
"I received these motions at 4 o'clock today, so I'll be abstaining on these resolutions," Smyth said.
Bennardo, who previously indicated he might support exceeding the tax cap to avoid significant service reductions, said the amendments provided an alternative worth considering despite their late introduction.
"I can't let perfect be the enemy of good," Bennardo said.
Other council members questioned how the town could suddenly identify enough changes to remain within the tax cap after months of warnings that doing so would require substantial reductions in services and staffing.
"At the very last minute on the night of the final vote, after months of being told otherwise and a workshop that happened just this morning, I'm being presented with a stack, from what I understand, that's forthcoming, of unvetted resolutions on the dais that suddenly claim that we may be able to stay under the cap after all," Lupinacci said. "My abstention is not an endorsement of an 18 percent tax hike," she added.
Councilwoman Jen Hebert supported the individual amendments but voted against the final budget because of concerns about transparency. She said the budget had previously been presented as a choice between an approximately 18 percent increase and significant cuts to town services and staffing.
"I don't support the way that we went about this, frankly," Hebert said. "I think that there should be more opportunities for the public to come and hear out the different details and get their questions answered."
Several Huntington residents welcomed the prospect of avoiding the proposed tax increase but questioned why the alternatives had not been developed earlier. While many welcomed the budget change, residents questioned whether the town would face similar financial pressures in the future.
"What assurances do we have that this will not repeat until 2028?" said resident Julian Beneforti. "That's going to be the big question going forward."
Michael Kornfeld, a nearly lifelong Huntington resident, also expressed appreciation for the effort to keep the proposed levy within the tax cap while agreeing the process lacked transparency.
"I'm very appreciative to the board for keeping the budget under the tax cap," he said. "However, I also agree with Councilwoman Hebert and Lupinacci that the way in which it was done, the process lacks such transparency, and I hope in the future that we can do this in a way that is much more respectful of our community, the people who are here, the people who are watching, the people who don't even know what is going on."
Denise Schwartz of East Northport questioned why dozens of amendments were introduced at the final meeting rather than during earlier budget workshops.
"I just can't believe the convoluted way that we got here as far as the budget," Schwartz said. "There were budget workshops. I watched those. There was a workshop this morning at 11 o'clock, which I realized I missed, and then watched the video because it was only 12 minutes long, which really shocked me because I thought this was a very important meeting as far as the budget. To come up at the last minute with an entire list of amendments — which could have been the way we presented the budget in the first place, or could have been discussed at those board workshops—really leaves a lot to be desired. Regardless of possibly being happy with the end result, this was a complete disaster."
Despite the failed final adoption vote, the amended preliminary budget remains positioned to become Huntington's 2027 spending plan under state law.
The proposed 18.39 percent levy increase has been displaced by amendments designed to keep Huntington within its calculated tax cap. Under New York Town Law Section 109, the amended preliminary budget will take effect if the board does not adopt another budget by Friday, Nov. 20.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Huntington Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.