Mid Hudson Valley
News Feed
Events
Local Businesses
Classifieds
Crime & Safety

I-684 Plane Crash Linked To Water In Fuel Tank, According To NTSB Findings

Investigators said water in both fuel tanks caused engine failure before a forced landing attempt on the highway in Westchester County.

Pressure testing found leakage around both fuel caps, according to the NTSB. (NTSB)

WESTCHESTER COUNTY, NY —Federal investigators said an airplane that crashed in a Westchester County highway median after losing engine power had water-contaminated fuel, with leaking fuel caps and an inadequate preflight inspection identified in the findings.

The airplane owner, who held a private pilot certificate and had recently purchased the aircraft, was flying with a commercial-rated safety pilot when the trouble began about 30 minutes after takeoff.

Subscribe

See Also: Victims Of I-684 Plane Crash In Westchester ID'd By Authorities

According to the report, the owner and safety pilot completed a preflight inspection and engine run-up and found no anomalies before departure. The owner was in the left seat and the safety pilot was in the right seat. The owner reported hearing an abnormal noise and seeing a loss of engine power, after which the safety pilot took control and one of the pilots told air traffic control they were diverting to the nearest airport, Westchester County Airport (HPN).

Shortly afterward, one of the pilots told the controller they had switched fuel tanks and restored engine power, but were continuing to the airport, according to the report. About two minutes later, the engine lost power again and the controller cleared the airplane to land. The safety pilot aimed for a forced landing on a road, but the owner voiced concern about landing opposite traffic, and the safety pilot then made a steep left turn toward another road the owner could not see.

The small plane would crash on the interstate highway near Exit 2 in the Town of Harrison.

A witness reported the airplane then fell, "...very fast out of the sky and crash[ed] in the center median" of the highway. Investigators later found water contamination in both fuel tanks, both carburetor bowls, the fuel supply hose to the right carburetor, and in liquid expelled from the engine-driven fuel pump. Examination of the engine found no discrepancies, and an extended test run revealed no anomalies.

The report said both fuel caps were closed and in place after the crash, but the left fuel tank cap had damage in two areas and was missing the o-ring or packing. The right fuel cap was undamaged, but its stud was not extended below the length of the self-locking nut. Pressure testing found leakage around both fuel caps.

Investigators also noted that about five months before the crash, water contamination in the fuel system caused the engine to stop immediately after engine start following an annual inspection. The root cause was not investigated at that time. Less than two weeks before the crash, the airplane underwent a second annual inspection, two days before the owner bought it.

The findings said it was likely the engine lost total power because water contamination in both tanks was not detected during the preflight inspection. Some or all of that water likely entered after heavy rains in the days before the crash leaked past the fuel caps.

More from Mid Hudson Valley
News | 2d
News | 2d
News | 3d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Mid Hudson Valley Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information