NEW YORK, NY — The three leading Democratic candidates seeking to replace retiring Rep. Nydia Velázquez largely agreed on many of the district’s biggest issues during Tuesday night’s NY1 debate, but they offered different visions of leadership, political identity and how to build progressive power in Washington.
City Council Member Julie Won, Assembly Member Claire Valdez and Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso debated immigration, housing, Israel and Gaza, public transit and campaign finance on Wednesday night ahead of the June 23 Democratic primary in New York’s 7th Congressional District.
Here are five takeaways from the debate:
Despite representing different wings of the Democratic Party, the debate revealed broad agreement on many major issues.
All three candidates opposed President Donald Trump's military action against Iran, supported maintaining New York City's sanctuary city policies, backed a pathway to citizenship for immigrants, supported the Interborough Express transit project, opposed congressional stock trading, and expressed opposition to unconditional military aid for Israel.
All three also raised their hands when asked whether the International Criminal Court's arrest warrant for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu should be enforced in the United States.
The debate featured policy differences, but voters looking for a dramatic ideological clash largely did not get one.
Valdez consistently staked out the most progressive positions on the stage.
She renewed her call to abolish ICE, repeatedly described Israel's actions in Gaza as genocide, advocated ending U.S. military aid to Israel, and emphasized her background as a union organizer.
"What kind of Democratic majority do we want to build?" Valdez asked during her opening statement. "One that fights for working people or one that serves the billionaires and war profiteers who've paved the way for fascism?"
Throughout the night, she framed her campaign as part of a broader movement that includes organized labor, democratic socialists, and grassroots activists.
While Valdez emphasized organizing and movement politics, Reynoso repeatedly pointed to his record in government.
The Brooklyn borough president highlighted accomplishments including police reform legislation, removing ICE from Rikers Island, housing advocacy, and borough-wide planning efforts.
"We need real fights and we need real results," Reynoso said during his opening statement.
Whenever discussions turned to housing, immigration, or coalition-building, Reynoso argued that his years in elected office gave him the practical experience needed to deliver results in Congress.
His campaign message centered less on ideology and more on proving he could translate progressive goals into policy victories.
Won sought to carve out a distinct lane between the district's various political factions.
While both Valdez and Reynoso are backed by major progressive organizations and political coalitions, Won emphasized her independence and repeatedly argued that Democrats should avoid internal divisions.
"This is one of the most divisive moments in politics," Won said. "It should not be this polarization within the Democratic Party."
She also highlighted aspects of her personal story that distinguish her from the field, including being the only immigrant, mother, and former technology worker in the race.
Won frequently referenced her experience in the tech industry and raised concerns about artificial intelligence and job displacement, issues largely absent from the other candidates' remarks.
The most contentious moments of the debate did not involve Israel, housing or immigration.
Instead, both Won and Reynoso challenged Valdez over outside spending supporting her campaign.
Won referenced previous statements opposing super PAC money and questioned whether Valdez was remaining consistent with those positions.
Reynoso followed with his own criticism, arguing that outside groups supporting Valdez were targeting wealthier portions of the district.
Valdez defended her campaign's fundraising operation by emphasizing its grassroots support, noting that more than 20,000 donors had contributed with an average donation of roughly $45.
Still, the exchange highlighted a growing debate within progressive politics about whether candidates can oppose the influence of money in politics while benefiting from independent expenditures made on their behalf.
New York's 7th Congressional District stretches across western Queens and northern Brooklyn and includes many of the city's fastest-growing and most politically active neighborhoods.
Queens
Brooklyn
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
New York City, NY Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.