Crime & Safety
NYPD Pro-Palestine March Crackdown Raises Policing Reform Doubts
Some civil rights lawyers are questioning the mayor's commitment to the deal in the wake of an aggressive NYPD response to a recent protest.

NEW YORK (AP) β When New York City resolved a lawsuit brought by Black Lives Matter demonstrators last year by agreeing to overhaul how police respond to protests, Mayor Eric Adams praised the suite of reforms as sensible steps to βmove our city forward.β
But some civil rights lawyers are now questioning the mayor's commitment to the deal in the wake of the New York Police Departmentβs aggressive response to a pro-Palestinian demonstration Saturday. Police arrested more than 40 people at the event and were filmed pummeling protesters and ordering them to leave the street.
At a press briefing Tuesday, Adams said officers had acted βaccordinglyβ in response to protesters who had spit at them, blocked traffic, lit flares and, in the case of one marcher, climbed atop a city bus with a Palestinian flag.
Find out what's happening in New York Cityfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The lawsuit settlement will require police to accommodate most street demonstrations, while creating a tiered system of responses that prioritize de-escalation. A city lawyer stressed that the city is still in the process of developing new training and procedures around the agreement, and it is therefore complying.
But Adams also argued that the protestersβ actions on Saturday negated the tiered approach, which is intended to ensure that police don't use isolated incidents of lawbreaking to crack down on otherwise peaceful protests.
Find out what's happening in New York Cityfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
βYou donβt have a right to disobey the rules. You were told to do it on the sidewalk. You were told to do it in a peaceful way,β said Adams, a Democrat and former police captain, adding that βwhen you cross over that line, thereβs no tier to that.β
Jennvine Wong, a supervising attorney at the Legal Aid Society, which is a party to the federal lawsuit, said the mayorβs comments raised βserious concern about his commitment to meeting the cityβs obligations under the settlement.β
βItβs one thing to be working on the policy and not having finalized them yet, but itβs another for the leadership of this administration to act so cavalier and dismissive about the ways this police department is ignoring the reality thatβs coming down the line,β she added. βTheyβre going to have to comply with every aspect of this settlement.β
The settlement, which does not have a deadline for implementation, stems from a lawsuit filed by New York State Attorney General Letitia James that found a pattern of civil rights violations committed by police against protesters who took to the streets in New York in May 2020 following George Floydβs death.
Under the new tiered system, the department must deploy fewer officers to most protests and refrain from sending heavily armored units that sparred frequently with protesters in the past. Moving to a high threshold requires authorization from a high-ranking commander and evidence of looming violence.
In an emailed statement, a mayoral spokesperson, Kayla Mamelak, said the city remained βcommitted to honoring the obligations of the settlement."
βOur efforts to date follow the exact structure outlined in the settlement, and any suggestion otherwise is simply untrue,β she added.
As fierce protests against Israel have broken out across the city in recent months, demonstrations have often been met immediately by officers in riot gear and threats of arrest if attendees do not disburse from the street.
Even before the beginning of Saturday's demonstration in Brooklyn, a large group of officers with batons, zip ties and shields were stationed at several points along the protest route, along with correctional buses used for mass-arrest processing, according to organizers of the event and legal monitors.
The Nakba Day event is held each year in Bay Ridge, a heavily Arab enclave of Brooklyn, to mark the forced expulsion of Palestinians following the establishment of Israel in 1948. It typically draws a small police presence from the local precinct, attendees said.
βThis felt like a show of force, an intimidation tactic,β said Nerdeen Kiswani, the co-founder of Within Our Lifetime, which organized the protest. βWe heard from community members all day that they had all these units spread out in the community.β
Shortly after Saturdayβs event began, Kiswani said, officers threatened arrests for those congregating in the street or using amplified sound. When one supportive community member played chants from a speaker in his apartment window, an officer scaled the buildingβs fire escape to tell him to stop, video of the incident shows.
In his comments on Tuesday, Adams suggested that many of those in the protests had come from beyond the neighborhood or the city, invoking his oft-repeated claim that outsiders who βdonβt like our countryβ are working to βradicalize our children.β An NYPD highlight-reel style video after the protest criticized the clothing of the protesters and the flyers they allegedly circulated online.
The settlement strengthens an NYPD rule requiring that officers maintain βcontent and viewpoint neutralityβ when responding to protests. But until it is formally implemented, protesters would continue to find themselves in a βgray zone,β said Wylie Stecklow, an attorney who represented protesters in the 2020 case.
βOur settlement agreement is trying to put guardrails out there to ensure constitutionally compliant policing,β Stecklow added. βAnd those guardrails are not yet in place.β