SHELTER ISLAND, NY — An elderly man who was the victim of a fraudster saw his $80,000 returned, thanks to quick-acting law enforcement agents, Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney said.
A rapid investigation commenced by the DA's financial crimes bureau and the Shelter Island Police Department led to the return of hacked funds wired from a Shelter Island man's Charles Schwab investment account into a regional out-of-state Federal Credit Union, Tierney said.
The name and location of the credit union are being withheld due to an ongoing investigation by authorities outside of Suffolk County, he added.
According to the investigation, the man discovered his Charles Schwab brokerage account had an unauthorized transfer of $80,000 on or around September 22, and learned that the wired funds were transmitted to an out-of-state credit union, the DA said.
Shortly thereafter, the man sought help from the Shelter Island Police department, whose detectives immediately reached out to the credit union to request the preservation of all funds, Tierney said.
They also requested assistance from the Suffolk County District Attorney's financial crimes bureau in serving subpoenas for the account records where the wired funds were deposited, the DA said. As the result of the "prompt actions" by the detectives and prosecutors, the credit union's fraud department froze the account, pending their own investigation, Tierney said.
Members of the DA's financial crimes bureau later conferenced with the credit union's compliance officer and the assigned out-of-state detective, Tierney said.
Prosecutors confirmed that the fraudulent account was closed and all deposited funds were returned to the Shelter Island man, as the rightful owner, the DA said.
"As I've cautioned many instances before, time is never our friend when it comes to hackers stealing funds from legitimate account holders," Tierney. "Our quick actions and cooperation with detectives on Shelter Island not only stopped the wired monies from being stolen by alleged criminals but also led to the credit union returning the funds to the victim. I urge members of the community to routinely check their bank accounts and notify authorities immediately if you think you have been scammed or hacked."
"One of the most critical actions a victim of a scam or financial crime can take is reporting the incident to law enforcement as soon as possible," said Detective Sergeant Jack Thilberg of the Shelter Island Police Department. "Early notification provides investigators with the best opportunity to track fraudulent transactions, identify those responsible, and work with financial institutions and partner agencies to pursue recovery of stolen funds."
He added: "Unfortunately, delays in reporting often reduce the chances of restitution, as funds can be quickly moved through a complex network of accounts and jurisdictions. If something feels suspicious or doesn't seem right, trust your instincts. Take a moment to pause, discuss the situation with a trusted friend or family member, and contact law enforcement immediately. Early reporting can be critical to protecting your finances and improving the chances of a successful investigation and recovery of your loss."
In addition, Tierney urged residents to be on high alert to avoid becoming a victim of similar hacks.
Tierney offered tips:
- Always protect your passwords and account information and never click on "pop-ups" or unsolicited texts or emails requesting account information or personal data, he said.
- Review your accounts frequently for balances and withdrawals, and never volunteer your personal information, including your banking information, without verifying the identity of the caller or emailer, Tierney said.
- Contact your financial institutions immediately if you see unauthorized deductions or withdrawals, he said.
"Above all, speak to a trusted individual, member of law enforcement, or the Suffolk County District Attorney's office if you are uncertain as to the validity of a transaction you are asked to complete," the DA said.
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
North Fork Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.