Community Corner
What Was Your Favorite Hilltop Dish? Or Memory?
Paying tribute to a 60-year-old tradition

Nyack's long-time Italian eatery is being demolished this month to . Read about the restaurant's history , and tell us what your favorite dish and/or memory was in the comments section.
Here's what other had to say:
- My husband loved the veal shank; although he was a big eater, he could never finish it! We only moved to Nyack in 1996, but we did get to eat at the Hilltop until it closed—usually twice a month.
- I loved the baked clams the best!
- My favorite thing at Hilltop as a kid was the stuffed artichokes. I'll never forget the day I brought my own daughter for her first Hilltop artichoke and the place was closed. It was very sad.
- The portions were always huge at the Hilltop... visiting family members who we took there to eat never complained that they didn't get enough to eat!
- I loved Hilltop's shrimp scampi.
- I grew up eating at the Hilltop almost every night. Sonny made the best clams over pasta as a lunch special; I still know the whole menu by heart. My mother and I ordered lobsters-to-go in a snowstorm and had a taxi pick them up for us! The best food and people ever! My families' home-away-from-home.
- Nobody did stuffed artichokes better than Hilltop. If it was late, like after a movie, we'd call to reserve a few before they were gone—artichokes, not seats.
- I ate there the night before my Desert Storm deployment. Moving up from the boroughs, it was the closest thing to my mom's Italian cooking in the area.
- When I was little my family would go there almost every Sunday for lunch after church. An open meatball sub, a burger or a double-order of clams posillipo were my favorites.
Find out what's happening in Nyack-Piermontfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
By subscribing, you agree to Patch's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.