Community Corner

Executive Order No. 1 Action #10 – Actively Oppose The Dissolution Of Consent Decree

In Syracuse, there is a Consent Decree resulting from an agreement between the City of Syracuse, New York, Onondaga County, and the US DOJ.

Press Release Desk, News Partner

Press release from the City of Syracuse:

12 October 2020

What is the Consent Decree that relates to the Syracuse Police and Fire Departments?

Find out what's happening in Syracusefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

A consent decree is a judicially-enforced order from a federal court to enforce an agreement negotiated between parties. In Syracuse, there is a Consent Decree resulting from an agreement between the City of Syracuse, New York State, Onondaga County, and the United States Department of Justice (“DOJ”). It went into effect in 1980, and is still in effect today.

How did the Consent Decree come into existence, and what does it mean?

Find out what's happening in Syracusefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

The Consent Decree was the result of a lawsuit filed in 1978 by the City of Syracuse, Mayor Lee Alexander and the City’s police and fire chiefs, against the New York State Civil Service Commission and Onondaga County. At the time, the City sought to increase the percentage of African-Americans and women in its police and fire departments, but viewed the legally-required state civil service examination as a barrier. Under NYS civil service law, the City must hire from among the three highest scoring candidates on the list of candidates who take a civil service examination. This is known as the “rule of three” and applies to all civil service tested jobs across New York State. The City alleged that this system, which was required by New York State and run by Onondaga County, was discriminatory and illegal because the police officer and firefighter exams were culturally biased and unrelated to true job performance for the jobs. Using the rule of three almost always resulted in the hiring of White, male applicants. Around this time, African American made up only 2.2% of the City’s police officers and 1% of its firefighters.

view consent decree court documents from syracuse.com

In 1980, DOJ started a similar lawsuit, seeking the same outcome as the City: to eliminate barriers to diversity for police officer and firefighter candidates. The two cases were joined together.

In 1980, all four parties – the City, New York State, Onondaga County and DOJ – came to an agreement that became the Consent Decree. The agreement recognized that:

  • the Syracuse police and fire departments should be representative of the community’s labor force;
  • historic imbalances in the City’s police and fire department hiring should be rectified; and
  • the flaws in the New York State civil service examination that contributed to these imbalances should be remedied.

The Consent Decree set a long-term goal to have African-Americans comprise all ranks of SPD and SFD in numbers similar to their representation in the City’s labor force. At the time, this percentage was 10% but has grown over subsequent decades. As a tool to reach that goal, the Consent Decree allowed the City to modify its hiring preferences and deviate from the rule of three in order to select African-American candidates.

In 2013, DOJ sought to force New York State to develop new police officer and firefighter civil service exams to remove any remaining bias. In the years that followed, the State and DOJ worked together to develop new exams. A new firefighter test was administered in Syracuse in April 2019, and a new police officer exam was administered in September 2019.

What is the current status of the Consent Decree?

Forty years later, the City’s police and fire departments are more diverse, but are still not representative of the City’s labor force. Currently, African-Americans comprise 17% of SFD and 9% of SPD.

The Consent Decree is still in place, but it is at risk. Based, in part, on the fact that new exams have been developed, DOJ is seeking to dissolve, or end, the Consent Decree. DOJ first notified the City of its intention on April 11, 2019. The City notified DOJ that it opposed ending the Consent Decree in a letter, dated May 23, 2019. Most recently, on September 4, 2020, DOJ formally filed a motion in the U.S. District Court, Northern District, asking the court to end the Consent Decree.

Why is DOJ seeking to end the Consent Decree?

Regarding the Syracuse Consent Decree, DOJ takes the position that the development of the new civil service exams for police officers and firefighters signifies the completion of the Decree’s goals, despite the fact that the demographics of the departments still do not reflect the local labor force.

What will Mayor Walsh do to oppose efforts to end the Consent Decree?

The City will aggressively oppose DOJ’s motion, and will argue to United State’s District Court, Judge David Hurd, that the Consent Decree should not be eliminated at this time because the original objectives of the Consent Decree are of equal importance today, and have not yet been met. Whether the Consent Decree remains in place or not will ultimately be decided by the federal court.

View City of syracuse Consent Decree Letter to J. Morrison (DOJ)

Timeline of Event

  • Right Now | The City is preparing its written legal opposition to the motion, which will be submitted to the U.S. District Court.

  • October 7, 2020 | A resolution was introduced at the Syracuse Common Council Regular Study Session memorializing the Council’s opposition to DOJ’s efforts to dissolve the Consent Decree.

  • October 13, 2020 | Council resolution is scheduled for a vote by the Common Council.

  • October 27, 2020 | The City will file its written opposition to the motion, which will be submitted to the U.S. District Court Judge David Hurd.

  • November 13, 2020 | The Court is scheduled to hear oral argument from the City and DOJ, and will render a decision on the fate of the Consent Decree sometime after this date.

    • Share your thoughts

    Related Stories

    Mayor Walsh Signs Syracuse Police Reform Executive Order

    Executive Order 16 provisions to strengthen police accountability Executive Order is part of Syracuse Police Reform Agenda that also includes engagement with stakeholders and protest groups and full compliance with Governor Cuomo’s Executive Order 203 Leadership and members of Syracuse Common Council join with pledge to advance Right to Know…

    19 June 2020

    New York State Office of the Attorney General Report on Officer Involved Shooting

    Joint statement by Syracuse Mayor Ben Walsh, Syracuse Police Chief Kenton Buckner and Syracuse Fire Chief Michael Monds on New York State Attorney General report on officer involved shooting: “The City of Syracuse received the Attorney General’s report this afternoon and is reviewing its findings. The report concludes the responding…

    24 January 2020

    City of Syracuse to Begin Deer Management Week of Dec. 2

    City issues “What Syracuse residents should know about Deer Damage Management" Information Sheet Deer management conducted by qualified wildlife managers from the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) will begin in the City of Syracuse during the week of December 2. Syracuse is one of five municipalities in Onondaga County…

    2 December 2019

    This press release was produced by the City of Syracuse. The views expressed here are the author’s own.

    More from Syracuse