Removal Of Downtown Lakewood Trees Causes Controversy

LAKEWOOD, OH — The cutting of trees in downtown Lakewood brought more than downed branches to the suburb.

City officials sparred over why the trees in front of Nature's Oasis were cut on Thursday. City Councilperson Tom Bullock said he tried to stop crews from damaging the Detroit Avenue trees, but was unable to halt the work.

On Thursday, Lakewood Arborist Dan Sullivan said the trees were removed because the city has received several complaints about the dangers they pose to pedestrians. He said trees are removed when they are diseased, dead or pose a threat to the public.

"The trees in front of Nature’s Oasis have been topped by utilities over the years, which forces side growth into the buildings. The sidewalks in front of the buildings are extreme tripping hazards and are being replaced as those problems develop," he said.

Nature's Oasis said on social media they will remain open while sidewalks are replaced and trees are removed.

The species of tree near the sidewalks was also problematic, Sullivan said. Locust trees were too large for that planting area and 75 percent of the roots would have to be removed to prevent further sidewalk damage.

While he agreed that some of the trees did pose an issue, Bullock wasn't convinced that all of the trees needed to come down at once.

"What's missing here is we've previously been able to get input from businesses in the community and the public and retain some of the trees over a period of time," he said. He advocated the gradual removal of problem trees, allowing certain shade trees to remain in place.

"We should be doing a staggered approach that would allow you to retain better trees and replace the others. Then, a few years in the future, we can take down the remaining trees and replace them," Bullock added.

Sullivan promised the city would plant new trees, of a different species, in that space in the spring. Nature's Oasis said on social media the arrival of new trees was "good news."

LakewoodAlive said it wants to consult with the city on future tree removal and replacement plans.

"We look forward to working with the City of Lakewood and the Tree Taskforce to identify street trees that can be saved and work on a replacement plan for those that cannot due to the health of the tree or sidewalk safety to ensure a vibrant and increased tree canopy,” said Executive Director Ian Andrews.