Arancini House Rated Best Pizza For Baldwin-Whitehall

BALDWIN, PA - The debate potentially can divide family and friends forever: Who has the neighborhood’s best pizza? Discussion on the topic can get as hot as the interior of a pizza oven.

In an effort to determine who has the best pie in and around the Baldwin-Whitehall area, we turned to Yelp users who never are shy about sharing their opinion. We don’t want you to be shy about sharing yours. Let people know if you agree or disagree with the rankings by posting your comments.

The highest-rated pizza joints are:

1. Arancini House, 615 Washington Road, Mt. Lebanon

The first thing we noticed about this place is that it’s not in Baldwin. But it certainly gets a lot of positive feedback. Offered one reviewer: “Hands down best Sicilian pizza I've had in Pittsburgh.” Opined another: The pizza was great; crispy outer crust yet soft and thick.”

2. Fiori’s Pizzaria 103 Capital Ave., Beechview

3. A’Pizza Badamo, 656 Washington Road, Mt. Lebanon

4. Michael’s Pizza Bar & Restaurant 2612 Sarah St., South Side

5. SLICE on Broadway 2128 Broadway Ave., Beechview

6 Donte’s Pizzeria, 6409 Brownsville Road, South Park

7. Il Pizzaiolo, 703 Washington Road, Mt. Lebanon

8. Santoro’s Pizzeria Italiana, 3805 Willow Ave., Castle Shannon

9. Beto’s Pizza, 1473 Banksville Road, Beechview

10. Danny's Pizza, 5159 Library Road, Bethel Park

Photo via Yelp.