Who Makes The Best Pizza In Dormont, Brookline?

DORMONT, PA No matter how you slice it, there's no disputing this fact about pizza: People like different types of pie, so trying to determine an area's best pizza places is a virtual impossibility; it's a matter of personal preference.

That being said, some pizza places around Dormont and Brookline appear to be preferred by more people than others, at least when it comes to Google reviews. What follows is a ranking of the two communities' top pizza joints based on the average number of stars received in reviews.

Agree or disagree with the findings? Leave your thoughts in the comments section below.

4.7 stars

• Fiori’s Pizzaria, 103 Capital Ave., Brookline

The high ranking is no surprise, as Fiori’s is not just one of the best pizza joints around Brookline or Dormont. It enjoys a reputation as being one of the best places in the city. Raved one reviewer: “It’s not just their delicious slightly sweet sauce, the dough is cooked absolutely perfectly and has an amazing crunch. Single slices are available and they're huge. Staff is super friendly.”

4.6 stars

• Don Campiti’s Pizzeria, 1509 Potomac Ave., Dormont

“Excellent pizza,” one reviewer opined. “Especially love the light sauce. It's very good. The crust is on the thin side, which I personally enjoy and they still use the cardboard and paper bag instead of a pizza box.”

4.5 stars

• Jet’s Pizza, 1810 Dormont Ave., Dormont

“Great Sicilian pizza. The crispy, caramelized crust and the generous application of sauce makes it special,” one reviewer wrote. “Very reasonably priced. Very quick service. Great place to stop by for slices.

4.4 stars

• Fox’s Pizza Den of Brookline, 902 Brookline Boulevard, Brookline

Wrote one reviewer: “Always pleased with the pizzas, cheesy bread and hoagies. Order from them all the time. Great prices too.”

4.2 stars

• Molly’s Pizza, 1525 Potomac Ave., Dormont

“Very good pizza, I've had both the deep dish and regular,” this reviewer wrote. “The people are always friendly here and the pizza (comes) fast.”

• Antonio’s Pizzeria, 702 Brookline Boulevard, Brookline

“My family and I have ordered takeout and eaten in this pizza place many, many times,” one reviewer related. “They have great staff and great food, I’m happy to say we have not had one bad experience with this pizza place and will continue to order from them.”

3.8 stars

• Vocelli Pizza, 3060 West Liberty Ave., Dormont

Sure it’s a chain, but chains are successful because people like their pizza. How much? Here is one example: “I absolutely love this pizza! So much better than those everyday chains. The staff was very personable and friendly.”

3.5 stars

• Vinny’s Pizza, 618 Brookline Boulevard, Brookline

One reviewer wrote: “Seafood pizza is wicked try it and tell me I am lying. Best pizza in months.”

• Angelina’s Pizza, 109 Brookline Boulevard, Brookline

“Fantastic sauce, good crust, and hard working staff,” this reviewer opined. “They never mess up my order, always have a great attitude, and deliver with in the time they say they will.”

• Uncle Tony’s Pizza, 3285 West Liberty Ave., Dormont

Offered this reviewer: “Fast delivery and excellent pizza. Their salads are generous and their topping numerous.”

Photo via Shutterstock.

Subscribe to Dormont-Brookline Patch for more local news and real-time alerts.