Across America
Seasonal & Holidays

A $12 Turkey Dinner, A $250 Feast And The Thanksgiving Traditions Families Won't Give Up

From a $12 Thanksgiving dinner to elaborate feasts costing hundreds, readers share what they're sacrificing and what they refuse to give up.

The food traditions that define the American Thanksgiving aren't inflation-proof, but many respondents to an informal Patch survey said they're willing to pay more to keep them intact.

Media (Pennsylvania) Patch reader M. King called it: "Norman Rockwell time at our place, inflation be damned."

Subscribe

With grocery prices up about 30 percent since 2020, Patch asked readers if their Thanksgiving celebrations will look different this year, what dishes are sacrosanct, and how much the meal will cost them.

For some readers, even a meager Thanksgiving meal is a struggle.

"I'm buying a really small turkey, and we'll go without dessert," Saline (Michigan) Patch reader Carolyn said. As for the rest of the meal, "I will purchase whatever I can get with $12," she said.

Avon (Connecticut) Patch reader Michael will be scraping by with "whatever I can find at the local food pantry this week." He's not planning a special meal Thursday, and anyway, he said, Thanksgiving is not his favorite holiday.

'Stuffing Can Kick Rocks'

(Shutterstock)

Most respondents to our informal survey said they'll keep their feasts intact, regardless of cost. Others are buying smaller turkeys, eliminating appetizers, reducing side dishes, limiting dessert options or skipping sweets altogether.

Turkey and stuffing are mainstays readers don't want to give up — mostly. "Stuffing can kick rocks," White Lake-Highland Township (Michigan) Patch reader Zacharia said.

And mashed potatoes and sweet potatoes are non-negotiable.

'Thanksgiving As It Always Is'

For Massapequa (New York) Patch reader Monica T., "the entire meal from start to finish is non-negotiable."

The spread in her Italian American household has "a lot of food," Monica said. "Antipasto to start. Then macaroni with all the tomato gravy-meat. Then the turkey and stuffing with all the sides and rolls. Then tons of desserts with coffee, both American and Italian demitasse."

Monica T. said she spends several hundred dollars on the Thanksgiving meal but avoids a big one-time hit on her bank account by shopping for non-perishable items weeks in advance.

"I would give up umpteen dinners out if I needed to to keep my Thanksgiving as it always is," she said.

Other money-saving tips offered by survey respondents included watching grocery circulars for sales, abandoning brand loyalty, shopping at multiple stores, cooking from scratch and taking advantage of free-turkey promotions. Potluck dinners also help spread the expense.

'More Simple Than Fancy'

(Shutterstock)

Westhampton-Hampton Bays (New York) Patch reader Tom said he is shopping sales and plans to "make as much as possible from scratch — baking bread for dressing and making cranberry sauce."

Tom's Thanksgiving meal will be "more simple than fancy — turkey, dressing (homemade), veggies, potatoes, cranberries, and rutabagas. Maybe just one pie, no fancy cheeses, just the basics."

Tom figures the whole thing will cost him about $100. "Food has increased so much," he said.

North Haven (Connecticut) Patch reader Tracey cut the appetizers and doesn't plan to make many pies. She'd sacrifice green bean casserole and rolls if she had to, but turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole and Na Na's yellow salad are worth saving for.

She didn't say how many people she's cooking for but said that even though she's shopping sales, she'll spend about $250.

Ridgewood-Glen Rock (New Jersey) Patch reader Rose is getting a free turkey under a store promotion and is also shopping ahead of time for "things that can be frozen or not go bad a little at a time to spread cost out." She also shops around for the best prices and cooks everything from scratch, including her famous sausage stuffing.

"With the free turkey, I can do dinner for less than $50," she said. "Look for sales and buy anything that can be made ahead of time when you see a good price."

A Hot Dog's OK With Family

(Shutterstock)

Thanksgiving holds the unofficial title as the biggest food holiday of the year, especially for single-day eating volume and meal-centered traditions.

But it's only food. Spending time with family and friends matters more, several readers said.

"Thanksgiving looks like family. As long as our family is together, it doesn't matter if we have hot dogs," Stonington-Mystic (Connecticut) Patch reader CB said.

Turkey, stuffing and cranberries will anchor Brooklyn (New York) Patch reader Laura's Thanksgiving table. She bought a smaller turkey this year and sacrificed some of the side dishes.

"The perfect Thanksgiving is family being together," she said.

It's The Work, Not The Cost

West Chester (Pennsylvania) Patch reader Bill plans to skip the "beautiful bird carved at the table, traditional sides and pie for dessert" this year.

It's not the cost of the feast, but the effort required to prepare it. This year, he's keeping the menu simple with grilled steaks and asparagus, a side salad, and a store-bought pie.

And we don't know if Zacharia, the White Lake-Highland Township Patch reader who's not fond of stuffing, was making a commentary on the economy or just joking in general.

But his idea of a perfect Thanksgiving is "friends, family, and deep-fried turkey using the same oil as last year."

More from Across America
News | 6h
News | 18h
News | 1d
See more on Patch >

Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Across America Patch

Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.

©2026 Patch Media. All Rights Reserved

Do Not Sell My Personal Information