Jury Deliberating Brendan Banfield's Fate In Au Pair Affair Murder Trial

FAIRFAX COUNTY, VA — The jury went into deliberations on Friday afternoon in the trial of Brendan Banfield, the Herndon husband and IRS agent accused of killing his wife and another man in a sprawling scheme involving his former au pair lover.

Jurors deliberated for several hours without reaching a verdict before going home for the weekend.

Both prosecutors and defense attorneys delivered their closing arguments to the jury on Friday, according to an NBC Washington report. The jury will now decide whether to convict Banfield of aggravated murder in the 2023 deaths of his wife, Christine Banfield, and Joseph Ryan, who authorities said were killed at the Banfield family's home in the Hattontown neighborhood in Herndon.

He could also be found guilty of two additional counts, including use of a firearm in the commission of a felony and child endangerment.

Banfield has pleaded not guilty and could face life in prison if convicted of aggravated murder.

Banfield took the stand in his own defense this week and said he never created “any sort of a plan” with Juliana Peres Magalhaes, the family's Brazilian au pair, to kill Christine Banfield.

“I think that it's an absurd line of questioning for something that is not serious, that a plan was made to get rid of my wife,” he said. “That is absolutely crazy.”

A Look At Murder Plot

Earlier in the trial, Peres Magalhaes testified that she began working as an au pair in the home in October 2021, when she was 21 years old. She and Banfield began a sexual relationship about 10 months later.

Banfield told her he wanted to marry her and have children with her, but he needed to “get rid of” his wife first, she testified. He didn't want to divorce his wife because “she would have more money than he would” and because he wanted custody of the couple's then-4-year-old daughter.

The killings happened at the Banfield home on Feb. 24, 2023. At the scene, police found Christine Banfield with upper-body stab wounds and Ryan suffering from upper-body gunshot wounds. Banfield was taken to the hospital and pronounced dead, while Ryan died at the scene.

Prosecutors previously said Banfield posed as his wife on a fetish website and lured Ryan to the home for what he thought was consensual sex. Banfield then shot Ryan in the bedroom and stabbed his wife, prosecutors have said, while Peres Magalhaes also shot Ryan.

Peres Magalhaes said both she and Banfield would both post to the site from Christine Banfield's laptop, and they were careful to post only when Christine Banfield was home.

“He knew that we needed to have some alibis,” she testified.

Details Of Slayings

In an interview obtained by NBC Washington last August, Peres Magalhaes said the morning of the slayings, Banfield pretended to go to his job but instead went to a nearby restaurant after instructing her to call him as soon as Ryan arrived at Banfield's home. Peres Magalhaes then took the child to a car under the pretense of going to the zoo.

When Banfield arrived at the home, he and Peres Magalhaes entered the house through the basement and left the child there. Banfield then entered the bedroom he shared with his wife with a gun drawn and announced himself as law enforcement, she said.

“When I got to the bedroom, he yelled, ‘Police officer,’” Peres Magalhaes said of Banfield. “Christine yelled back at Brendan, saying, 'Brendan! He has a knife!' That's when Brendan first shot Joe.”
Peres Magalhaes previously told prosecutors that Banfield took Ryan’s knife and stabbed his wife multiple times.

"He was stabbing her, and she was just telling him, 'Let me go. I'm gonna die anyways. I'm gonna bleed to death,'” Peres Magalhaes said. “She was just, 'Leave me here. Let me die.' And he was telling her, 'I can't.' I don't know why he said 'I can't.’"

John Carroll, Banfield's attorney, said in opening statements that Peres Magalhaes had maintained her innocence for a year but eventually changed her story in exchange for a sweetheart deal.

The prosecution's theory relies on the idea that Banfield and Peres Magalhaes were “catfishing” Ryan by pretending to be Christine Banfield. However, the lead homicide detective and the forensic detective both disagreed with that theory, Carroll said. Both were later transferred. Carroll said there was “turmoil” inside the police department over that case that some media have dubbed the “au pair affair.”

“You’re going to see a presentation of a horrible, tragic, awful event,” Carroll said. He said there is no dispute that Banfield and Peres Magalhaes were having an affair; however, “there’s an awful lot more to look for.”