Politics & Government

Ridgefield Public Safety Facilities Committee Reviews $56M Joint Police-Fire HQ, Two Costlier Alternatives

Ridgefield officials review three public safety building options costing $56 million to $71.2 million, with public input planned.

RIDGEFIELD, CT — A proposed combined police and fire headquarters on Danbury Road would cost approximately $56 million, substantially less than two alternatives involving separate facilities, according to preliminary estimates presented to Ridgefield's Public Safety Facilities Committee on Nov. 18.

The committee reviewed three building configurations with estimated total project costs ranging from $56 million to $71.2 million. Members said the figures require additional review before they can recommend a plan to the Board of Selectpersons.

Committee Chair Steve Scalzo announced that the Board of Selectpersons had extended the committee's deadline for submitting its final report from Nov. 18 to Feb. 1, 2027. The extension will allow members to examine the estimates, review fire response times and obtain public feedback.

Find out what's happening in Ridgefieldfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Related: Ridgefield Extends Public Safety Building Deadline, Reviews Parking Changes And Budget Requests

Scalzo said the committee has generally favored a combined facility because of potential construction and operating efficiencies, but emphasized that alternatives remain under consideration.

Find out what's happening in Ridgefieldfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

"Our focus and our preference has been a joint building specifically because it provides fiscal and economic efficiencies," Scalzo said.

He said the committee had examined multiple town-owned properties during nearly a year of work and had narrowed its options after evaluating potential sites.

Three Proposals Range From $56 Million To $71.2 Million

Architects from Kaestle Boos Associates and representatives of Nasco Construction Services presented updated designs and preliminary construction estimates for three options.

The combined facility would occupy the town-owned properties at 217 and 221 Danbury Road. The two alternatives would place a new fire headquarters on Danbury Road and construct a separate police headquarters either at the existing East Ridge Road location or on Old Quarry Road.

The estimated total costs are:

  • Combined police and fire headquarters on Danbury Road: Approximately $56 million.
  • Separate fire headquarters on Danbury Road and police headquarters on East Ridge Road: Approximately $71.2 million.
  • Separate fire headquarters on Danbury Road and police headquarters on Old Quarry Road: Approximately $69.5 million.

Todd Costa, a principal at Kaestle Boos Associates, said the estimates include construction, equipment, furnishings, design services, project oversight and other indirect expenses.

The combined facility carries an estimated construction cost of $46.9 million, along with approximately $3.6 million in equipment expenses and $5.5 million in indirect costs.

The Danbury Road-East Ridge Road alternative includes approximately $57.8 million in construction expenses, $3.6 million for equipment and $9.8 million in indirect costs.

The Danbury Road-Old Quarry Road alternative includes approximately $59.6 million in construction expenses and $3.6 million for equipment, with lower indirect costs than the East Ridge Road option.

Costa said the East Ridge Road alternative would require temporarily relocating the Police Department while its existing headquarters is demolished and replaced. The department would then move into the completed building, adding relocation and operational expenses.

The Old Quarry Road option would avoid that temporary relocation but involve more extensive site preparation, including retaining walls and grading.

The estimates do not include property acquisition costs, which committee members said were excluded from their assignment.

Architects Detail Combined Facility

Sean Schmigle, an associate principal at Kaestle Boos Associates, presented updated plans for the combined headquarters.

The design would place police and fire operations in separate sections of one building while allowing the departments to share certain facilities, including training and wellness areas.

See Also: Ridgefield Residents Challenge State Development Authority Plan Over Branchville Housing, Sewers

The fire section would contain seven apparatus bays, firefighter living quarters, administration offices, equipment storage and decontamination facilities.

The police section would include patrol and administrative offices, detention facilities, evidence storage, dispatch operations and secured parking.

Schmigle said the site would accommodate approximately 140 parking spaces, including 12 public spaces, 71 secured police spaces and 57 spaces designated for the Fire Department.

The architects also discussed vehicle circulation, emergency response access, snow removal, security measures and possible future expansion.

Committee member Pamela Dunaway questioned whether the plans provided adequate parking for community programs and whether the building could accommodate future departmental needs.

The architects said additional parking could be made available for special events and that limited expansion might be possible, although adding another occupied floor would require additional planning and expense.

Costa estimated that the proposed buildings would have a useful structural life of approximately 40 to 50 years with regular maintenance, although mechanical systems and other components would require replacement sooner.

The combined facility was estimated to require approximately 18 to 20 months of construction.

Separate Facilities Present Additional Challenges

Schmigle also presented a standalone fire headquarters design for the Danbury Road property.

Unlike the combined building, the standalone fire facility would extend into an upland review area associated with nearby wetlands.

Schmigle said the design would require additional regulatory review and might be adjusted to improve fire apparatus turning movements.

Director of Public Works and Facilities Jacob Muller said preliminary test pits on the property showed generally favorable subsurface conditions, with no significant rock or groundwater problems encountered during the initial investigation.

Additional testing and the usual land-use permitting would still be required, Muller said.

At East Ridge Road, the architects evaluated replacing the existing police headquarters rather than renovating it.

See Also: Ridgefield Finance Board Reviews $3.75M Battlefield Property Purchase, Delays Funding Decision

Costa said keeping the department operating within an active construction site would disrupt police operations and extend the project schedule.

The current estimate therefore assumes the department would relocate temporarily while the existing building is demolished and a new facility is constructed.

The architects said a replacement building could incorporate exterior details reflecting the character of the surrounding historic district while meeting modern police security requirements.

The Old Quarry Road alternative would place a new police headquarters on a comparatively level section of the property, although the site would require retaining walls potentially reaching 8 to 10 feet.

Estimator Explains Construction Costs

Ed Hiney, vice president and chief estimator at Nasco Construction Services, said the firm developed its estimates by evaluating individual construction components and comparing them with costs from similar police and fire facilities.

The estimates account for foundations, structural materials, security features, mechanical systems, site improvements, contractor expenses and anticipated construction cost increases.

Hiney said the calculations include a 10 percent design contingency and a projected construction cost escalation rate of 4.75 percent.

He cautioned that the figures remain preliminary and could change as the designs become more detailed.

"We have to start off with a budget, with a realistic budget," Hiney said.

Committee member David Brickley said he wanted the architects and estimators to review the figures again to ensure that no significant costs had been overlooked.

Secretary Ed Tyrrell raised similar concerns about indirect expenses, saying the committee should avoid presenting a funding request that later proves insufficient.

Costa said the firms would review their calculations and supporting documents before the committee moves forward.

Fire Chief Supports Revised Design

Fire Chief Rommie Duckworth expressed support for the Danbury Road designs, particularly improvements in apparatus circulation.

He said the architects had addressed concerns about maneuvering large emergency vehicles without interfering with traffic or delaying responses.

Duckworth said the ability to move apparatus within the property was an important consideration in replacing the existing facilities.

The committee was also awaiting a fire response-time analysis from JB Consulting Group.

Muller said a draft was expected the following week and would be distributed to committee members for review.

He also clarified that a separate traffic signal grant application was not part of the public safety facility cost estimates.

Committee Plans Public Feedback Session

Committee members discussed scheduling a public information session before completing their recommendations.

Dunaway said early January appeared more practical than December because of the holidays and the time needed to verify costs, coordinate presenters and prepare comparisons of the three options.

She said the public presentation should include the estimated effect on taxpayers and a comparison of each proposal's advantages and disadvantages.

Tyrrell emphasized that residents should have enough time to provide meaningful feedback before the committee submits its report.

Members discussed Jan. 6 and Jan. 13 as possible dates for a public session, but neither date was finalized.The committee also discussed meeting again in early December.

Scalzo said the additional time would allow the committee to incorporate public comments into its final report rather than simply present a completed recommendation.

The committee approved minutes from its Sept. 30, Oct. 14 and Oct. 28 meetings, with a correction to the Sept. 30 attendance record.

The committee is scheduled to submit its findings to the Board of Selectpersons by Feb. 1, 2027.