Cops: Woman Punched Twin Over Sex Toy, Boyfriend

A 48-year-old Bradenton woman faces a battery charge after Manatee County Sheriff’s deputies say she punched her twin sister during an argument over a man and a sex toy.

The incident unfolded around 1:30 p.m. Sunday at 5535 36th Court E, deputies say.

Heidi Creamer is accused of getting into a verbal spat with her twin, Holly Ryan, “over Heidi’s boyfriend and a sexual toy (vibrator),” a probable cause affidavit stated.

That report says Heidi punched Holly in the face, knocking her to the ground. Holly retaliated by kicking her sister. The fight, the report said, continued with Heidi pushing, scratching and pulling Holly’s hair.

Heidi then grabbed some of her belongings from the home and said she wanted to leave. Holly obliged by locking her out and going up to her third-floor balcony to yell at neighbors to call 911, the report said.

See Also:

• Burglar Caught Sleeping on the Job
• Florida Man Challenges Cops to a Race, Loses
• Butt Dial to 911 Lands Woman Behind Bars

The deputy that responded found Heidi outside banging on the door and Holly on the balcony with blood on her face. After Heidi was read her Miranda rights, she told the deputy the dispute was “over a vibrator and her boyfriend,” the reported stated.

Heidi was booked into the Manatee County Jail on a charge of battery. She was later released on $500 bond. Creamer has been arrested several times in the past on charges including battery, DUI and possession of a controlled substance, jail records indicate.

Heidi Creamer/Manatee County Sheriff’s Office