Politics & Government

FL AG Targets Bradenton Private School Over Student Expulsions, Book Complaints

FL's attorney general is questioning a Bradenton private school after students were expelled following parents' objections to assigned books

BRADENTON, FL — Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier is seeking answers from a Bradenton private school after several students were expelled following parental objections to classroom reading materials, raising questions about the school's curriculum and tuition policies, according to multiple reports.

Uthmeier's office is reviewing potential violations of Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act involving Saint Stephen's Episcopal School, ABC 7 reported.

The dispute involves parents from multiple families who raised concerns about books assigned to students that they claim contained sexually explicit material and LGBTQ-related content, reports said.

Find out what's happening in Bradentonfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

In a letter Uthmeier sent last week to Head of School Peter Kraft, he accused the school of expelling children of parents who complained about the instructional material they considered sexually explicit and containing LGBTQ content, the Sarasota Herald-Tribune said.

Families were told before enrolling their children that the school's curriculum would be free of LGBTQ-related instructional material, the attorney general’s letter said. The school's handbook also prohibits pornography, obscene language and sexually suggestive content on campus.

Find out what's happening in Bradentonfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Among the books cited by Uthmeier are "The Poet X" by Elizabeth Acevedo, "Girl" and "Annie John" by Jamaica Kincaid, and "Answers in the Pages" by David Levithan — material that the attorney general argued contains sexually suggestive content that conflicts with the school's stated policies, reports said.

"Private schools, rightly, have some independence, but when you are marketing yourself as an institution that's going to protect kids from harmful content, content that's too mature for younger grades, content that's pornographic or sexual in nature, you've got to live up to that marketing," Uthmeier said in his letter to Kraft, according to Fox 13. "We expect our young kids to be in a safe environment. As a private school, you're not completely immune from government regulation and oversight."

After parents raised objections through the school's established process, the school terminated the students' enrollment, citing its Standards of Civility policy, the attorney general’s letter said, according to reports.

The families also reportedly didn’t receive refunds for their full-year tuition payments. The school's enrollment contract makes families responsible for a full year's tuition and fees even if a student withdraws voluntarily or involuntarily, Uthmeier reportedly said.

His office contends that the school's representations about its curriculum and its handling of the parents' complaints could constitute deceptive business practices.

The attorney general has demanded that the school preserve records related to the matter, stop attempting to collect tuition from the affected families, refrain from withholding student transcripts and make the families financially whole. He also requested a response from the school by Nov. 30, reports said.

Saint Stephen's Episcopal School officials said they acted appropriately and will cooperate with Uthmeier’s investigation.

"We will cooperate fully with the Attorney General's office and are confident we have acted ethically and in accordance with our Educational Values, policies, and Florida law. We look forward to providing the AG’s office with the facts and documentation they’ve requested,” the school said in a statement to Fox 13, adding, “In the meantime, we will continue to fulfill our mission of providing students with outstanding academic, spiritual, and moral education.”

See Also:

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.